Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simply astonishing, Sep 7 2003
This review is from: 1998 Saint Francois D Assise (Audio CD)
Olivier Messiean is one of the handful of 20th century composers whose work does this maddening sentury justice. Impossible to catergorize,and often difficult to listen to, he brings listeners in with his unique combination of Eastern modalities, Catholicism, bird calls and luminosity. Completed when he was 75, St Franois is his masterpiece,his only opera. At over 4 hours, its is decidely not backround music,nor casually expierenced.When given the time, though its is overwhelming in its rewards.Sounding at times like Phillip Glass than Puccini,Messiean tells the story of St. Francois in 8 vignettes, done in three acts{and over 4 discs}. Kent nagano studied this score with Messiaen himself to the extant that it is almost his own{ Nagano is sort of THE messiean conductor}, and is a daunting task for anyone else to tackle this work{Though it was done with great success In San Francisco earlier this year}. Naganos is the only version in entirety I have yet heaRD, SO IT REAMINS FOR ME THE BENCHMARK. Jose' Van Dam is Francois here, his voice at times low and rumbling, at others the perfect instrument of God[as messiean intended} There are no female voices until dawn Upshaw arrives as the voice of the Angel,over an hour into the opera. And, as always, Ms Upshaw is what she plays,perfect as the angel. There are times when the opera sags[the Sermon to the Birds goes on a bit,well, it comprises all of disc 3},though that is a minor quibble. This is not an easy expierence,though it is not required that one for an opera afficianado,either. It is , in my estimation, the greatest Opera of the 20th century, and one of the greatest musical statements in recent history. Do yourself a great favor, get this listen to it over a period of time. Perhaps, in some mystical fashion, Messiean intended this music to make people better by the simple [or not so simple] act of hearing it? It has , at the very ;east, made me more open and willing musically, and that, in itself, is magical. A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
For open minded music lovers, Mar 25 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: 1998 Saint Francois D Assise (Audio CD)
This is, if you like modern classical music, a must have. Like an earlier reviwer said too... I usually not like Naganos conducting but he is VERY good here and this is def. not an easy piece to conduct. Every singer then is doing a fantastic job even if they not at all sound so french all the times but it doesnt matter. Conducting, sound, singing, music and choir is at top level so dont hesitate to buy this opera. One of Messiaens greatest works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not easy but a must, Aug 2 2000
This review is from: 1998 Saint Francois D Assise (Audio CD)
This is not an easy opera. It is important to keep this in mind. A good amount of effort will be needed in order to enjoy this music, especially if you are not fond on modern classical music or of the music composed by Messiaen. After saying this, if you are still interested in this kind of music, i got to say this is an impressive opera-. Don't expect passion like in the italian operas or lots of sound like Strauss but slowness and spirituality. It seems that nothing happens but when you enter into the opera you'll feel the hipnotical quality of the music and the introvertion that keeps going on along the opera. There are some really extraordinary moments such as when Saint Francis meets his angel when you can have an insight of Heavens. Well, that's what Messiaen tries to do it and he really gets it. The belgium baritone Van Damn is extrordinary as saint Francis, altough i still the old Orfeo performance with Fischer Dieskau. Some of the other singer, altough, are not french native speakers and you feel the difference. I mean, lots of times they don't sound french at all. The american conductor Nagano was a close friend of the composer and they worked together on this score, so he knows perfectly well the score ( i want to make clear i'm not a great fan of Nagano, he is at his best here but i think this score really deserves a better conductor). Saint Francis has been a legend for many years. It's an opera that any really opera lover should, at least, know. This is an excellent opportunity to get to know this difficult but wonderful work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|