Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
She's still got it, Dec 27 2003
This review is from: 2002 Winter Marquee Live (Audio CD)
After two disappointing albums from Nanci Griffith, "Winter Marquee" is a delightful surprise. Not to mention a definite improvement over her one other live album, "One Fair Summer Evening," which I give five stars for performance but one star for sound quality - that one always sounded to me like the final mix was phoned in. This time around, Griffith and friends are in fine form and it feels like you're in the audience. Most of the songs are among her best-known ones, but Griffith is one of those performers who can make even old favorites sound fresh on stage. Classics like "I Wish It Would Rain" and "Listen To the Radio" are just as addictive here as the first time you heard them, and "Gulf Coast Highway" (never among my favorites from her catalog, but I know I'm outvoted on that one!) gets yet another righteous revival. "I'm Not Drivin' These Wheels" and "Traveling Through This Part of You" get my votes for this collection's biggest revelations; the studio versions of both were always a bit forgettable for me, but the performances here are irresistible. The covers are also terrific. This performance of John Prine's "Speed of the Sound of Loneliness" tops both the original and Griffith's previous recording of it, but Julie Gold's "Good Night New York" really steals the show. Written years before 9/11 as a tribute to past generations of immigrants, it unavoidably has more than one meaning now. There is only one new original song featured here, "Last Train Home" (at least I think it's new), but it's a scorching Texas tale which features some of her all time best lyrics, guaranteed to make good use of your "repeat" button. Here's hoping she's written more songs like this one for the next album - and in the meantime, this one is a more than welcome addition to her collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Winter Marquee, Oct 23 2003
This review is from: 2002 Winter Marquee Live (Audio CD)
This disc adds little new to Nanci Griffith's corpus. Chances are you've already heard most of these songs. But there's a certain spark in live folk and country that makes this CD eminently worth listening to. Recorded (the liner notes don't say where) on the "Clock Without Hands" tour, this CD features both recent and older. It brings tunes like "Listen to the Radio" back into play, and it also allows her to try on the music of others. She covers classic songwriters like Phil Ochs and Bob Dylan, and current major names like John Prine and the late Townes Van Zandt. Griffith is one of those gifted musicians, rare in this day of teen-pop and boy bands, who sounds as good live as in the studio. It's a joy to listen to her swing through the tracks, plainly loving making music as much as we love listening. She's backed by a skilled band who fill out her sound, and they really help her sound good. This is the kind of CD you can stick in the player and listen to over and over again. I have, in fact, done so. I recommend you do the same.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Same old Nanci!, Dec 23 2002
This review is from: 2002 Winter Marquee Live (Audio CD)
This album is well played, well sung and enjoyable. However there's nothing new on here that we haven't heard from Nanci before. There's no outstanding live versions of tracks we've heard before (The live version of love at the five and dime from "One Fair Summer Evening" fills out and expands the song from a short album filler to a titanic tale of love found lost and found again), and the new tracks don't tug at the heartstrings or linger long in the memory (although her previous studio album clearly showed that she can do that with (for me) "Armstrong" being one of the best songs she's ever sung. I think one of the reasons may have been the dropping of the narrative between songs which were such a highlight of "One Fair Summer Evening" - talk to any Nanci fan about popcorn machines and you'll bring back the whole introduction with references to vanilla cokes and getting off the bus at South Austin. Buy the DVD instead! I'm going to
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|