2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
So at last, I got it. It's entirely beyond my control., Feb 13 2009
This review is from: 2046 (DVD)
2046 is truly a masterpiece. A lot of people do not understand it, but I did some research before watching it, so I knew to pay attention.
First, without subtitles everyone speaks their own language (so one person might speak mandarin to someone speaking Japanese); so a lot of reviewers got confused. The DVD HAS SUBTITLES and is therefore easy to follow.
The theme is about how a sad romantic past (a lost true love) can leave you emotionally "out of sync" unless you understand that by trying to recapture your past feelings, you are cutting off your ability to fall in love because your emotional anchor is looking backward. You see, the past is fixed, so it cannot change -- you can rely on the past, but the future because it is not establish fact yet, makes one feel powerless to affect the outcomes. So people just "give up" because there are too many variables that would need to come together to make that "perfect feeling of love" to happen again.
2046 is a summation of two other movies this Director made .. "In the Mood for Love", primarily; but also "Days of Being Wild". In the Mood for Love's main link is the hotel room number 2046, which is the room where the lovers met. The love affair does not have a happy ending because the conditions needed to make it work seem outside their control, so they break up. So you see the pattern being questioned in 2046 -- we ponder that "timing is important" but do we surrender any impact on future timing by giving up on finding true love.
In 2046; there are several stories, but the one involving Miss Wang (Faye Wong) and her Japanese boyfriend, is essentially a simpler version of the story the main character went through in "In the Mood for Love".
NUMBERS .. okay you have to keep track of numbers as there are some fun hints given using numbers. For instance, areas 1224 and 1225 are symbolic of Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.
THE ROOMS - 2046 is where his romance happened years ago. He tries to move into 2046, but has to take 2047 down the hall (hall symbolizes time). He can watch 2046 from 2047 and this is where Miss Wang and Bai Ling live.
The story takes place in Hong Kong, in the mid to late 1960s. 2046 is a future novel the main character is writing; keep in mind this the the future as seen in the 1960s (so not how we see the future now). That said it is really a future setting where the 2046 TRAIN meanders through the city endlessly. The neat thing is that people go to 2046 to rediscover their forgotten past (they attempt to come to terms with it). Therefore, in 2046 nothing ever changes; but no one is certain it is real because no one ever returns from there - they get stuck on the train. So 2046 is a room, a time, a train, and a place. To escape 2046 you essentially have keep working to win your love no matter how impossible it seems. To achieve success you have to endure terrible injury and be patient for the timing to work out.
Back to the writer. Since his failed romance, we open with him saying how he has become a womanizer and does not need a serious relationship - in fact he has changed a lot since "in the mood for love" where he was innocent and loving. Here the women love him, but he gives them "his time" in repayment. But he wants nothing beyond a surface fun friendship. Essentially, he has given up on falling in love because it is out of his control. We see the story of the special women in his life .. and all the people end up in the novel eventually - Lulu jealous boyfriend, Miss Wang, the Hotel owner (Miss Wang's dad) become the Train Captain of 2046 for instance.
**SPOILERS BELOW**
The stories weave around each other. The one that shows us how to escape 2046 is that of the sad story of Miss Wang and her Japanese boyfriend (wonderful actor BTW). Miss Wang is forbidden to see her boyfriend because he is Japanese, and the father would disown her if she saw him (Japan was not good to China during the war). She begins to talk to herself - repeating over and over the words she wished she could have said - I will come with you. Her story takes a break as she is eventually hospitalized; returning later in the story, a shell of her former self. The writer has been observing her relationship and is touched by her perseverance and sacrifice (played so sweetly by the girl)--she knows her situation is hopeless but she seems unable to give up. He eventually surprises us by helping her out by having the boyfriend's letters sent to him, and slipping them to her privately so her father is not mad. She eventually helps him write for the summer, and he falls in love with her - but she longs for her boyfriend. He then gives her a gift by writing a new novel called 2047 where he wants to show her how he sees her relationship with her Japanese boyfriend. He says that the more he wrote about the Japanese boyfriend, the more he felt he was really writing about himself. There is a change though - notice the two quotes below from his 2046 and 2047 novel.
FROM 2046: "I once fell in love with someone. After a while she was gone. I couldn't stop wondering if she loved me or not. I went to 2046 hoping to find her there. But I never found her."
FROM 2047: "I once fell in love with someone. I couldn't stop wondering if she loved me back. I found an android which looked just like her. I hoped she would give me the answer."
We go to a dinner scene with Bai, which seems to serve no purpose, but shows us how she went looking for the writer the previous Christmas, and he was not there .. similar to 2046 quote above.
Also, from 2047 - he has figured out the emotional damage people get -- "Our cabin attendants are superbly designed... But there's only one problem: when they've served on so many long journeys, fatigue begins to set it. For example, they might want to laugh, but the smile would be slow to come. They might want to cry, but the tear wouldn't well up till the next day... "
In the 2047 the Japanese character TAK concludes - "So at last, I got it. It's entirely beyond my control. The only thing left for me... was to give up."
The writer then has dinner with Miss Wang - he asks her if she has heard from her boyfriend. She says she stopped because the situation was impossible because of her fathers feelings. The writer concludes - it is only impossible if you give up (take "no" for an answer), and offers to take her to the newspaper office so that she can call her boyfriend. The expression he has as he looks in through the window is touching -- as she makes her call - he says he felt like Santa that year.
Mr Wang meets up with the writer to say that he is off to Japan for his daughter's wedding. The writer asks why he is so happy when he detests the Japanese - and the father says he has learned that all he wants is for his daughter to be happy. So the impossible has happened. Mr Wang adds .. "my daughter loved 2047; but wishes you would change the ending as its too sad." Which begs the question - can our main character get a happy ending himself.
He tries and tries to change the end of his story but is locked. He meets Bai again for dinner, and she give him money -- $10 bills he had given her when they were very much a couple - and watches as he pays for dinner with the money. She knows she means little to him. She asks him to stay but he refuses ...
"He didn't turn back. It's AS IF HE BOARDED A VERY LONG TRAIN headed for a drowsy future through the unfathomable night"
In short, he knew he was stuck in 2046 forever because he had given up. He was able stop the couple from giving up and they got out.
The only theme I've not touched upon is the "single gloved hand" .. simply put it shows a past undisclosed but visible to everyone. Much like a scar.
One factor that might help clarify the story flow; is that there are really two stories put together here. The story of Bai (Zhang Ziyi) would almost stand alone, but it gives background to the conclusion we need. Something to keep in mind as it makes the flow make way more sense.
This movie hits so close to true on so many levels. The photography is really interesting, and the music stunning. I highly recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No