5.0 out of 5 stars
A moody classic, Mar 10 2006
This review is from: A Curious Feeling (Audio CD)
I originally bought this album a couple of decades ago and to be honest the muddy production was a bit of a turnoff. I eventually forgot the album, but bits and pieces of tunes from the album kept surfacing in my memory. I couldn't remember where they were from, but they just wouldn't go away. Then a couple of years ago I was going through my old LP collection and found ACF. I put it on the turntable and was just blown away by this bittersweet symphony! The story is heartbreaking, as is the music in many places. The ending fanfare on "Forever Morning" is one of the most evocative pieces of music I've ever heard; I can just imagine someone waking and standing while watching a glorious sunrise to that music... the droning organ combined with the strings creates and overpowering wall of sound. It also makes the character's downfall through the rest of the album much more touching.
This is definitely an album that grows on you. Forget the average production, the average singer; listen to the melodies, the lyrics and the orchestra-like instrumentation. A classic, period.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best progressive album, ever., Jan 11 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: A Curious Feeling (Audio CD)
I'm old enough to have heard just about everything "prog rock" has to offer. And I'm the first to admit there is much to be ashamed of (the excesses of ELP, the vocals of Marrilion, the musical ugliness of Dream Theater, Asia, Genesis after Wind & Wuthering, later incarnations of King Crimson, and so on). No wonder so many people hate complex music!
But there have been a few moments of real joy, beauty and musical thrills. In The Court Of The Crimson King, A Trick Of The Tail, Stand Up, Chicago #1, Shades Of Deep Purple, The Doors, In Memory Of Elizabeth Reed, McDonald & Giles, Smallcreep's Day, Spectral Mornings, Anthony Phillips' 1984 and anything by the still undiscovered Kevin Gilbert. You're either nodding your head or have no clue to what this paragraph says....sorry.
If you had any doubts, A Curious Feeling makes it clear Tony Banks was the musical "brains" behind Genesis. Everything good from Genesis is traceable to him and/or Anthony Phillips. The one thing he can't do is sing and on this album, he doesn't.
Its fair to say if you like Genesis you'll love this disc. But please don't lump this in with crap like Follow You, Follow Me. This is the real deal. And while you're at it, pick up 21st Century Schizoid Band's album. Thirty years on and these guys still write and play better than the big current acts.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Gorgeous, with reservations, Oct 27 2003
This review is from: A Curious Feeling (Audio CD)
You can really hear Tony's contributions to Genesis on this album. Those gorgeous chord progressions, even in their simplist forms, are so reminiscent of his work with Genesis. The instrumental songs are lush; the vocal songs are very good. "Lucky Me" is such a beautifully composed song, and "For A While" sounds instantly familiar even if you've never heard it before - it's just one of those naturally appealing songs. My only gripe is with the horribly dissonant fourth verse of the chorus in "Somebody Else's Dream": for me, that just ruined an otherwise powerful song with magnificient chords. The CD sound is a bit veiled and soft, but a great album anyway.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No