Most helpful customer reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
Introducing a Female Bernie Gunther, Aug 9 2010
This is a great debut and unabashedly Philip Kerr-like in setting, atmosphere and plot. In fact, I kept expecting Hannah Vogel to hire Bernie Gunther or at least bump into him at the Adlon. And this is not a criticism because Cantrell pays homage to Kerr's work but goes her own way too through the lead female character. It is a decent mystery and educates the reader on the excesses of the Weimar Republic (and the soon-to-be excesses of the Nazis). Using Ernst Roehm as a pivotal character to expose personal and political depravity is a fresh choice from the usual Nazi leadership figures who appear in fiction. I will definitely read the author's follow-up, A Night of Long Knives.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellen first novel.., May 2 2010
Rebecca Cantrell shows life in that "iffy" period in German history, the Weimar Republic, which preceded Hitler's official ascendency to power in 1934 as Chancellor under Hindenburg. Germany society had been restabilised from the low point of trillion-mark inflation of the '20's, but everyday life was still difficult, even for those, like Hannah Vogel, who had a job. She was a newspaper reporter for Berliner Tagablatt, writing crime stories under an alias. She's also a widow of a WW1 soldier, and the sister of a much-younger brother, Ernst, who is gay and works as a singer in a gay bar. He has many unusual friends and associates and one day winds up floating in the River Spee. He's unidentified and his picture is posted on the wall at the "Alex", the main police station in Berlin, where Hannah sees it while going through police reports. She doesn't want to identify her brother, but begins to investigate his disappearance and murder. She gets involved with his many associates - some more shady than others - and begins to really see the political dynamics of the times. It's a well-written novel - Cantrell's first - and I'd love to read more of her work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
35 of 36 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Full disclosure . . ., Aug 18 2009
By Bruce L. Ginier - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Trace of Smoke (Hardcover)
. . . this is my first book review on Amazon. Reading A Trace of Smoke is like settling into a comfortable chair, right smack in front of a massive open window with all the sights, sounds, and smells of a strange new world unfolding in front of you. Cantrell writes about a time and place that I knew little about, early 30's Berlin at the start of the Nazi rise to power. She weaves a tight plot of murder and suspense through the hard and unforgiving shadows of Berlin, and propels it forward with a cadre of historical and unique fictional characters that makes you flinch, gasp, and keep turning the page. It's a world I didn't know and story I wasn't expecting, but I want more of both. Impressive.
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Read from a Hot New Talent, Jun 12 2009
By Andrew Peterson, author of "First to Kill... - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Trace of Smoke (Hardcover)
Rebecca Cantrell hits a homerun with her stunning debut. The plot is intricate and her characters engaging, especially young Anton. Hannah Vogel, Cantrell's main character is believable and charming, yet tough as nails. I won't spoil the plot, but the ending took me by surprise. I read it in three sittings. My only complaint is that the book ended! I'll be buying Cantrell's next books. She's got a new fan for life.
23 of 27 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
powerful historical tale, May 12 2009
By Harriet Klausner - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Trace of Smoke (Hardcover)
In 1931 thirty two years old crime reporter for the Berliner Tageblatt Hannah Vogel visits Berlin's Hall of the Unnamed Dead. There on the wall is the picture of an unknown naked corpse whom she recognizes. The victim is her beloved gay brother Ernst, who could not harm a fly; he had no papers because he gave them to their Jewish friends to escape dangerous Germany for New York. Outraged that someone would torture and kill her effeminate kind sibling, she knows she must remain silent re his identity or her "lost papers until their friends reach America. Still Hannah investigates using Ernst's sexual proclivity and his performing at the underground El Dorado cabaret as the starting points With the help of her dedicated lover and a young urchin claiming to be her nephew, Hannah makes her inquiries including the claim of the street kid that her obviously gay brother sired a child. This is a powerful historical tale that looks deep inside the souls of the groups that make up the Weimer Republic at a time when Hitler is just starting to rise in power. The story line contrasts caring people from various religions vs. the brutal angry assaults of the Nazis. Not an easy read with no sugar coating, A TRACE OF SMOKE will have readers pondering whether this could happen in modern day America. Harriet Klausner
|
|
|