there is only 1 real problem I find with this tent, but it is only a problem if you would expect something different. that is, the floor material is no thicker than the wall material. If you buy this, make sure you buy the chaos 2.0 floor saver as well to go under it, or I doubt you will enjoy your tent for very long.
I give this tent a 5 though, because, well, a floor saver will save the floor, and should be used with any tent. the aluminum poles are amazing; especially with the lower price of this tent. By myself, on my first try, with no directions, I set the tent up in 10 minutes. It is very tight! this is good. Can comfortably fit 2 people with gear. Lastly, it is pretty packable. It fits back into its carrying case with a little less effort than you would think (still isnt easy). Packs small, I can fit it, along with my sleeping bag into the bottom part of my backpack. Very lightweight for a 2 person free-standing tent. Minor Edit: Also, the stakes that come with it, made me quite happy. Pencil-sized aluminum stakes. About 2X the diameter of what you would expect to come with a tent.
When my hiking season comes to an end in september, I will re-review this if my opinion changes.