3.0 out of 5 stars
Very good story, page turner - with flaws, April 21 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: APOCALYPSE TROLL (Mass Market Paperback)
I picked this up at Borders, and got involved. Like the guy says below, it's not a bodice-ripper. It's a military sci-fi story, and it's quite good. It's got his usual clearly monstrous bad-guy critter(s) that nobody would have any problem killing.
Like much of Weber's stuff, he has excellent battle scenes, and as long as the scene makes sense as a decision that seems reasonable, it's great. Only thing is, that at critical points it doesn't seem reasonable. The final battle scene - well - given the setup, it would have been handled differently. Wouldn't have been an infantry battle. Would have been 1, maybe 10 nuclear missiles instead. I just can't believe anyone would make that decision, because of the risk.
But it's a good story. I'm just a stickler for authenticity of details at all levels.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Well-written mil-SF/romance, fast-paced & fun., Jan 22 2004
This review is from: APOCALYPSE TROLL (Mass Market Paperback)
____________________________________________
As Apocalypse Troll opens, 25th-century humans have been at war
with the alien Kanga for centuries. The Kanga are on the ropes; in
desperation they send a battle group into Terra's past, to cut off the
foe at the roots. BatDiv 92, Terran Navy is soon in hot pursuit. The
two task forces virtually annihilate each other. Col. Ludmilla
Leonovna shoots down the last Kanga ship -- with some help from
the US Navy of 2007 -- but is herself shot down by the last cyborg
Troll's fighter. She falls to Earth, and into the arms of USN Capt.
Richard Aston:
"Take me to your leader", she said with a perfectly straight face.
The last Troll is at large, with 25th-century weapons and a
bioengineered compulsion to waste humans. Ludmilla must
convince 21st-century Earth of the terrible danger they face...
Ludmilla is demonstrating her
sidearm: < *BIG* flash-bang here >
"What the hell *is* that thing? What d'you call it?"
"I'm afraid we call it a 'blaster'," she said apologetically...
It's all good, clean fun and brother, do those pages turn -- this one
kept me up til 2 AM. Everything *works* here -- the people, the
aliens, the future technology, the battles, the romance .... I had a great
time, and so will you.
Apocalypse Troll is Weber's 18th published novel, but apparently was actually his first written, some ten years ago. This would have been a very impressive first novel -- I have no idea why it ended up as a "trunk" novel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining, and not quite what the blurbs have you believe, Dec 14 2003
I picked up The Apocalypse Troll at a used book stall for a school fundraiser, and didn't look too carefully at it. When I got home to peruse my purchases, I wasn't at all sure that I'd gotten something I'd normally find worth reading. The back blurb promises that our hero "has his hands full of an unconcious, critically wounded and impossibly human alien warrior who also happens to be a gorgeous female"; the inside cover starts "My People are as human as you are! (said the beautiful space alien)"--you get the picture. And, true, there are moments like this in the book, but it isn't primarily a sci-fi bodice ripper, thank heavens, nor done as clumsily as this. Mostly the book is a very entertaining sci-fi/military adventure. Although I'm no expert, the jargon seemed authentic and the story, given the standard dose of disbelief most sci-fi needs, quite credible.
The story is quite a bit like Star Trek: First Contact, except that Weber's version of the Borg, instead of being sluggish robots you can tiptoe around, are vicious, vigorous supercyborgs which literally wipe out or assimilate anything in their path. They make much better villans than Picard's nemeses; so much so that they actually make it back to Earth in the past and have to be hunted down by their only surviving opponent. It's a fun read, not particularly deep but not at all pretentious, either.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No