Haven't watched "All I Want for Christmas" yet, but all the reviews indicate that "The Christmas Card" was the better of the two. In that case, we'll never watch the other one! I really wanted to like "The Christmas Card" as I usually love sentimental holiday movies, but it was beyond BORING and utterly predictable. My husband literally slept through the whole thing and I truly had a hard time staying awake myself. I didn't care about the characters and there wasn't really much plot to speak of. Still not really sure why the main characters ended up together, or better yet, why we should even remotely care.