5.0 out of 5 stars
Great cd!, Jun 3 2006
This review is from: American Idol: Greatest Moments (Audio CD)
I really enjoy Kelly Clarkson's voice and I think this cd just proves why she's the one who first won the contest. Amazon's songs listing of this cd lightly differs from what it is in reality, which is the following (it's mostly the same songs but not in the same order). I would give 10/10 for each song.
1.) Natural Woman (Kelly Clarkson)
2.) Respect (Kelly Clarkson)
3.) For Once In My Life (Justin Guarini)
4.) Get Here (Justin Guarini)
5.) Piece Of My Heart (Nikki McKibbin)
6.) A House Is Not A Home (Tamyra Gray)
7.) Lately (RJ Helton)
8.) Ain't No Sunshine (Christina Christian)
9.) If You Really Love Me (Ryan Starr)
10.) My Cherie Amour (A.J. Gil)
11.) I'll Be (EJay Day)
12.) Easy (Jim Verraros)
13.) Californa Dreamin' (Top 10)
14.) A Moment Like This (Kelly Clarkson)
15.) Before Your Love (Kelly Clarkson)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
One leap from "Thankful.", Jun 11 2004
This review is from: American Idol: Greatest Moments (Audio CD)
This is the cd that shares all of the top 10 finalists talent. From Kelly's "Natural Woman" to Nikki's "Piece Of My Heart" even to the finals song "A Moment Like This." We go through a full summer on this cd with songs from each artist Tamyra to Justin to Ryan Starr. Here is my play by play of the songs (only rate)
1.) Natural Woman (Kelly Clarkson) 9/10
2.) Respect (Kelly Clarkson) 8/10
3.) For Once In My Life (Justin Guarini) 9/10
4.) Get Here (Justin Guarini) 8/10
5.) Piece Of My Heart (Nikki McKibbin) 9/10
6.) A House Is Not A Home (Tamyra Gray) 10/10
7.) Lately (RJ Helton) 8/10
8.) Ain't No Sunshine (Christina Christian) 10/10
9.) If You Really Love Me (Ryan Starr) 9/10
10.) My Cherie Amour (A.J. Gil) 5/10
11.) I'll Be (EJay Day) 10/10
12.) Easy (Jim Verraros) 9/10
13.) Californa Dreamin' (Top 10) 10/10
14.) A Moment Like This (Kelly Clarkson) 10/10
15.) Before Your Love (Kelly Clarkson) 10/10
Overall, this album gets a B+. Better luck with an A+ next time!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
American Idol, Jun 2 2004
This review is from: American Idol: Greatest Moments (Audio CD)
This was a great! Cd with the 10 finalist of American Idol.
1. You Make Me Feel Like A) Natural Woman-Kelly uses her gritty and sultry voice to make this aretha classic her own. This is the voice that made her win. I still wonder why there is no high note. Oh well she does awesome. 10/10
2. Respect-Kelly comes in with this song that made her awesome on American Idol. She does great in her rendition of it. She does some spectacular singing here. 10/10
3. For Once In My Life-Justin gives a good song. He had a good voice i hate the harmonica solo. But over all a good song. 8/10
4. Get Here-Im not a big fan of Justin or his voice. But there is no denying that there is talent. This song was a little slow for his smooth voice. Not My Favorite. 7/10
5. Piece Of My Heart-Ehh Nikki has a way to gritty rocky voice unsoothing. Not a Fan. At All. She isnt close to the worst though. 6/10
6. A House Is Not A Home-Tamyra is so awesome. She made this song spectacular with her soothing, smooth voice. I love her rocky grunt singing in the end where she picks it up ending with a acapella held note. Really Great. The track of this Cd in my opinion. 10/10
7. Lately-He isnt good like Simon said LOSER. Studio magic can only help him so much. Worst track by FAR. 2/10
8. Ain't No Sunshine-Christina give a good performance i thought the song would pick up. No she does the annoying repete of "I Know" Still good. 8/10
9. If You Really Love Me-A good song. Ryan does a good job. She did all that she could in my opinion. She is nothing special but not bad. 7/10
10. My Cherie Amour-I thought it wasa a girl at first. No its A.J. the whole song is basicly lalalala bad. 3/10
11. I'll Be-By EJay jeez to many RJ,AJ,EJ to many j's none are good. Ya not good. 4/10
12. Easy-Jim Verraros is better than all the J's should have stayed longer pretty good. 8/10
13. California Dreamin-Each singer gets about a line. Ou of the ensemble. To Much Justin. Not enough of Kelly she got about 2 words in. while everyone else got a full line.
14. A Moment Like This-A awesome song. Kellys single. Better than all the songs on here but i dont consider it with the others since it was recorded for kelly's single and CD. 100/10
15. Before Your Love-Good but compared to Kellys first single come on! Still a good song for Kellys single and cd. 9/10
A GREAT CD with highlights Kelly and Tamyra. Love it!!!!!!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No