American Passage: The History of Ellis Island Hardcover – May 21 2009
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
“Mr. Cannato’s writing is vivid and accessible, and his approach is admirably even-handed.” (The Wall Street Journal)
“Historian Vincent Cannato appears to have overlooked nothing in telling the tale of the historic island, now a national monument. . . . Cannato is not only a meticulous researcher and historian, he’s also a lively storyteller. A rare combination.” (USA Today)
“Cannato does a masterful job of weaving together a slew of singular immigrant stories with the larger issues that surrounded newcomers. He gives us the politics, the health scares and epidemics, the crowding, the corruption and the public policy.” (The New York Post)
“Cannato navigates the crosscurrents of immigration since the 1700s, illustrating his tale generously with odd facts and highly readable stories.” (Associated Press)
“The story of America is one of immigration. By bringing us the inspiring and sometimes unsettling tales of Ellis Island, Vincent Cannato’s American Passage helps us understand who we are as a nation.” (Walter Isaacson, author of Einstein)
“Reading Vincent Cannato’s American Passage was an amazing journey into our nation’s immigrant past. Never before has Ellis Island been written about with such scholarly care and historical wisdom. Highly recommended!” (Douglas Brinkley, author of The Great Deluge)
“Immigration has long been a critical slice of the American narrative, and here, in American Passage, Vincent Cannato tells its story with great brio. From landing point to national Monument, from immigrants to interpreters, we see the veritable Babel of Ellis Island play out across the years.” (Jay Winik, author of The Great Upheaval and April 1865)
“To his great credit Cannato does not pretend to answer our tough questions about immigration, nor to find a ‘usable past’ in the history of Ellis Island. He just tells one heck of a story that oozes with relevance.” (Walter A. McDougall, winner of the Pulitzer Prize and author of Throes of Democracy)
“Although Ellis Island is about immigrants from far-away places, it is in fact as American as Thanksgiving and apple pie. This amazing story is recounted beautifully in Vincent Cannato’s well-written and evocative book, which will bring pleasure and profit to readers.” (Kenneth T. Jackson, editor in chief, Encyclopedia of New York City)
“Cannato resists the temptation to setimentalize Ellis Island. He understands that, now as then, immigration is an issue that leaves Americans uncomfortable and contentious, even as it continues to bring new blood and energy into the country.” (Jonathan Yardley, The Washington Post)
From the Back Cover
For most of New York's early history, Ellis Island had been an obscure little island that barely held itself above high tide. Today the small island stands alongside Plymouth Rock in our nation's founding mythology as the place where many of our ancestors first touched American soil. Ellis Island's heyday—from 1892 to 1924—coincided with one of the greatest mass movements of individuals the world has ever seen, with some twelve million immigrants inspected at its gates. In American Passage, Vincent J. Cannato masterfully illuminates the story of Ellis Island from the days when it hosted pirate hangings witnessed by thousands of New Yorkers in the nineteenth century to the turn of the twentieth century when massive migrations sparked fierce debate and hopeful new immigrants often encountered corruption, harsh conditions, and political scheming.
American Passage captures a time and a place unparalleled in American immigration and history, and articulates the dramatic and bittersweet accounts of the immigrants, officials, interpreters, and social reformers who all play an important role in Ellis Island's chronicle. Cannato traces the politics, prejudices, and ideologies that surrounded the great immigration debate, to the shift from immigration to detention of aliens during World War II and the Cold War, all the way to the rebirth of the island as a national monument. Long after Ellis Island ceased to be the nation's preeminent immigrant inspection station, the debates that once swirled around it are still relevant to Americans a century later.
In this sweeping, often heart-wrenching epic, Cannato reveals that the history of Ellis Island is ultimately the story of what it means to be an American.See all Product Description
Top Customer Reviews
I really did enjoy reading this book, but I did find that most of the text was more informational rather than Cannato answering his historical question. The best section of the book I found was actually at the end when Cannato analyzes the myth and memory of Ellis Island in the contemporary context. The questions he raises about the concerns both African Americans and Native Americans in that America's "immigration story" has all but written them out of.
The book is very well-researched, based on many primary and secondary sources, I just found that it contained a lot of superfluous information. The book could probably have been cut in half with more interpretation rather than explanation. Overall, this is a decent survey into Ellis Island and America's immigration policy in the twentieth century.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
The book goes through the entire history of Ellis Island, from its first incarnation as a place to hang criminals, through its various stages of immigration reception, through the many changes and renovations made to it, and finally to the tourist attraction (and national treasure) that it is today.
I had occasion to take my wife, two of my chilren, and my two granddaughters to Ellis Island a few years ago, and I was in awe of the place, and couldn't believe what my forebearers had to go through so that I could be there observing. Using the computers there, we were able to find my father's father, and my wife's mother's father, and learned how and when they arrived on our shores.
The book says that names weren't changed by officials there, but I tend to disagree. My grandfather's name was Appolinarious (sp?), but it was changed to Paul at Ellis Island. It's easier to say, because in Polish his name is pronounced much differently than it is written above.
We should all take some time out to see this place, and then stop to admire and thank our ancestors for having the courage to come to a new land and raise their families.
Cannato shows that the vast number of immigrants of the Ellis Island era, while not from the preferred parts of Europe like earlier immigrants, were by and large hardworking individuals who sought to have their own little piece of the American dream. The great struggle regarding which group should be admitted and which group should not is mapped out in epic detail. He also does a wonderful job at demonstrating the internal political struggles that beset Ellis Island during its peak years of operation.
Cannato also shows that not all the immigrants who came into the country during this period were of ideal motives. Where the book tends to drag is that it draws too much from leaders and senators and does not offer a balanced view by showing successful immigrants. However that does not stop this from being a very interesting story and an interesting read.
Of course, when his great-grandfather came, there were no tests for newly arriving immigrants, anyone who wanted to come could immigrate here (so long as they weren't Chinese), so saying he came legally is meaningless, and the Ellis Island immigration station did not exist.
In fact, if your ancestors came before 1892, they definitely did not come through Ellis Island.
But since so many people think their families got their start there, the truth may be less relevant than the perception.
I am always on the lookout for books on American immigration history, so I was happy to come across a new history of Ellis Island. American Passage, unfortunately, is only partially successful in telling the story of the iconic place of American immigration.
There are many ways to tell the story of Ellis Island. Vincent Cannato chooses to begin his telling with the story of feuds between various officials at the immigration station. Bureaucratic infighting is rarely interesting, and the fights among the big-wigs at Ellis are no different. The first third of the book is taken up with who said what to who sort of nonsense. Hardly a grabber.
And, while the next two hundred pages do a good job of describing the Ellis Island experiences of immigrants and immigration officials, the final fifty pages discussing the legacy of Ellis offer few real insights.
This book is only half full.
But let me dwell on what was useful in the book, without necessarily recommending that you read it.
First, Ellis was a place where until 1920 just about any white immigrant seeking to come into the U.S. was allowed to enter.
No visas. No limits on the number of immigrants. No extensive medical exams. No police background checks.
Less than 2% of those showing up at Ellis were turned away.
Second, Ellis became a place of exclusion after World War I because of the threat of Eastern and Southern European immigrants overwhelming America. America at the time was much more heavily immigrant than it is now and immigrants were much less likely to learn English and assimilate. This generated for many white native born citizens a fear of cultural suicide.
For example, a Congressional investigation reported that Slavic and Italian immigrants came to the U.S. to work and send money home, not to put down roots here. The official report described them as eating food "that would nauseate and disgust an American workman. Their habits are vicious, their customs are disgusting."
MIT president Francis Walker described the new immigrants as "ignorant, unskilled, inert."
Alabama Congressman William Oates, who at one time had taken up arms against the United States and killed American soldiers, said there "are thousands of people in this country who should never have been allowed to land here. Many of the Russian Jews are no better than the Italians. Mining camps are overrun with the most beastly ignorant foreign laborers."
When Ellis Island was set up, immigrants were lucky that its first director was a Republican Civil War hero named Col. John Weber. Weber had gone to Europe to study the persecution of the Jews there before serving at Ellis. Unlike many of his contemporaries, he was extremely sympathetic to the refugees from the pograms, as well as to other immigrants seeking a better life. A man who had shown bravery in battle, he also displayed moral courage in countering those who disparaged immigrants. He wrote that "the evils of immigration are purely imaginary in some cases, greatly exaggerated in others."
In 1903, 857,000 immigrants passed through Ellis Island in a single year. 60% were Italians, Jews, or Slavs. They were mostly male, unskilled, and nearly half were illiterate. One report claimed that 68% of the Italians couldn't read in any language.They had, on average, $9 ($150 in today's money) in total liquid assets upon arrival and no job waiting.
The director of Ellis Island that year was William Williams, a Puritan throwback. He said that a quarter of all immigrants were of "no benefit to the country". He actively worked with the Immigration Restriction League (IRL) to limit immigration.
The IRL worried about the supplanting of the white race by Jews and Southern and Eastern Europeans. Prescott Hall, the founder of the group asked; "Is there a danger that the race which has made our country great will pass away and that the ideals and institutions which it has cherished will also pass?"
Ellis Island chief Williams shared the racial concerns of the IRL. In his official report on immigration in 1911 he wrote that the "new immigrants proceed from the poorer elements of the countries of southern and eastern Europe and from backward races with customs and institutions widely different from ours and without the capacidty of assimilating with our people... Many possess filthy habits and are of an ignorance which passes belief." In case you missed it, he's talking about your grandparents here if you are Italian, Jewish, or Polish.
When Williams was accused of anti-Semitism after the publication of his report, he responded that he was merely stating "sociological facts".
The IRL began working with the American Breeders Association to advocate for the exclusion of genetically inferior immigrants. IRL chief Prescott Hall, who was himself a sickly depressive, said that our immigration policies should be redesigned to only allow in the genetically superior who would one day breed what he called a "superman to produce a better world."
Williams shared Hall's concern over the poor genetic stock arriving from Eastern and Southern Europe. He brought in a psychologist named Henry Goddard to test new arrivals. Goddard initially found that 83% of Jews and 79% of Italians tested were feebleminded. Goddard complained that Jews could not answer simple questions. For example, when the psychologists asked them to define a table, the Jews would answer that it was place to sit at and eat.
Americans came to fear that mentally deficient immigrants were swamping their mental institutions. This was a false fear, of course, since only 5% of mental patients were immigrants, while they made up 15% of the population of the U.S.
Luckily for the Ellis immigrants, Dr. Howard Knox was placed in charge of certifying the intelligence of immigrants. He disparaged Goddards work saying it used tests designed originally for middle class French school children on working class immigrants. For example, middle-aged Polish peasants were asked to make up poems with particular rhyme schemes.
In another test, immigrants were shown a picture of three young children mourning a dead pet called "Last Honors to Bunny". They were asked to describe it. Cannato writes that; "Hard as it may be to believe, some immigrants had little familiarity with pictures. More importantly, many immigrants were puzzled by what they saw in the drawing. They had rarely seen pets treated well and were not used to seeing rabbits as pets. Some were unfamiliar with the practice of placing flowers on graves."
Knox also mocked Goddard's use of head shapes for classifying people's intelligence. In one case, a man was identified by Goddard's team as low "on the evolutionary scale." When Knox tested him, he found the man spoke three languages fluently and was highly intelligent (if a bit ugly).
World War I was used by the anti-immigrant crowd to pass increasingly restrictionist laws. The new immigration laws cut new arrivals by 75% or more. It even more dramatically redirected 20th Century immigration away from Southern and Eastern Europe. For example, in 1914, 296,414 Italians entered the United States. In 1920, the quota for Italians was reduced to 40,294. By 1924, it was further reduced to just 3,845! Greeks fared even worse. They were cut from 3,000 to only 100!
The Immigration Restriction League appauded the new laws because they had the courage to "discriminate in favor of immigrants from Northern and Western Europe, thus securing immigrants of homogenous stock."
With the passage of the 1924 immigration law, supported by the KKK as well as the IRL, Ellis Island's role as the entry point for new immigrants went into decline. Americans became more interested in slamming the Golden Door shut than in lifting a lantern next to it.
A totally interesting read that surprised me with it's pathos,accuracy and insight. A must read if you have ancestors that came through Ellis Island or are just interested in reading a very down to earth accounting on how the immigration process evolved.