Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another marvel from the inventive mind of Fred Vargas, Sep 5 2011
This review is from: An Uncertain Place (Paperback)
On a trip to London, Commissaire Adamsberg and his second-in-command, Commandant Danglard, go along on a Scotland Yard call to Highgate Cemetery, where they see a dozen-plus pairs of shoes----complete with severed feet----lined up as if to enter the gates. When they return to Paris, they are called to investigate a murder in which the victim's body has been pounded into unrecognizable pieces. The investigation takes Adamsberg on a trip to Serbia to try to find the origin of what appears to be a centuries-old family curse involved in the murder of his Paris victim. His sleuthing leads to a connection between his Paris murder, the bizarre Highgate scene and corruption in high levels of French government. Not only that; he discovers that Blagojevic is a despised name in certain circles in Serbia, not just Illinois! Along the way, Adamsberg delivers kittens, receives several chiropractic adjustments, is put in life-threatening danger twice, receives shocking news about his past, eats a lot of delicious-sounding Serbian food and gets quite an education in the lore of vampires. In other words, not your everyday mystery book. The Adamsberg series is filled with indelible characters, from the shy, introspective, often-unfathomable but lady-killing Adamsberg, to his team of quirky investigators, to the always vividly-drawn characters who are unique to each title in the series. Where many detectives are cynical, hard-drinking tough guys, Adamsberg is wide open to life, with all its full spectrum of wonders. After viewing the unimaginably gruesome Paris crime scene, he observes to one of his detectives: "'[W]hen you've seen something like that,' said Adamsberg softly, 'a bit of it sticks and stays inside you. Any experience that's too beautiful or too horrific always leaves some fragment of itself in the eyes of people who have witnessed it. We know that. In fact, that's how you recognize . . . [s]omething either overwhelmingly beautiful or overwhelmingly terrible . . . You recognize it by the shock, the little splinter that remains.'" Here is Adamsberg on Lieutenant Retancourt, 110 kilograms (242.5 pounds) of raw power: "Did she know that to him she represented his tree of salvation, a tree with tough and miraculous fruit, the kind of tree you put your arms around without being able to encircle it, the kind of tree you climb up into when the mouth of hell opens?" In this book, there isn't nearly enough of Retancourt and the other members of the team, like Danglard, Froissy and Estalere. But there are other unconventional characters who assist Adamsberg, like Vladislav Moldovan, Adamsberg's Serbian translator, who is completely covered in sleek black hair and laughs at everything, and Émile, the pugnacious, small-time chiseler and murder suspect who has a weakness for a tiny terrier named Cupid. With all the idiosyncratic characters and their often whimsical style, Vargas's books could easily descend into fatal cuteness, but they never do. There is a real depth of feeling to them, the stories and atmosphere are always unique and Vargas is able to convey a sense of place so real you will feel as if you've been on a trip. It's not for nothing that Vargas has won the prestigious International Dagger Award three times and been a finalist for Gold and International Dagger Awards an additional three times. As another reviewer notes, this title can stand on its own; you don't have to have read the other books in the series first. However, you will appreciate the story better if you are more familiar with the recurring characters. I recommend reading the series in the following order: The Chalk Circle Man: A Commissaire Adamsberg Mystery (Commissaire Adamsberg Mysteries) Seeking Whom He May Devour: Chief Inspector Adamsberg Investigates (Chief Inspector Adamsberg Mysteries) Have Mercy on Us All: A Novel (Chief Inspector Adamsberg Mysteries) Wash This Blood Clean from My Hand: A Commissaire Adamsberg Mystery (Chief Inspector Adamsberg Mysteries) This Night's Foul Work: A Commissaire Adamsberg Mystery (Chief Inspector Adamsberg Mysteries) An Uncertain Place: A Commissaire Adamsberg Mystery
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Weird, witty & wonderful, May 22 2011
By Patto - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: An Uncertain Place (Paperback)
My head was spinning from all the mad twists of this novel - but pleasantly spinning, as from a fast waltz. It never ceases to amaze me how Fred Vargas gets me to buy into her wildly weird plots. This, the newest Commissaire Adamsberg mystery, is as terrific as all the others. Maybe the best yet. Inspector Adamsberg is chief of the Serious Crimes Squad in Paris. He gets results, but no one can fathom how. His thoughts are as aqueous as mist or sea spray. He's more interested in the odd, irrelevant detail than in hard evidence, which he distrusts. His interrogations sometimes put suspects to sleep. He drifts into bed with women rather too easily. His staff - despite idiosyncrasies that include narcolepsy, Anglophilia, eating disorders and compulsive drinking - are amazingly effective under his direction. Adamsberg encounters two bizarre crimes in this book. While at a conference in London, he and his associates happen upon a collection of 17 shoes holding dead feet, abandoned in front of historic Highgate Cemetery. Back in Paris, Adamsberg gets caught up in a grisly murder. The victim, a wealthy misanthrope, has been minutely dismembered and pulverized. These two seemingly disparate crimes will lead Adamsberg into terrible confusion and mortal danger. He'll be confronted with vampire legends on the one hand, and dark political doings on the other - and some ghosts from his own past. I'm being deliberately vague about the plot (beyond what the publisher reveals) so as not to deprive readers of any of the shocks ahead. Vargas is a brilliant writer, especially good at creating absurd characters that we can't help but like and outrageous situations that become totally involving. "An uncertain place" is a real location in this book, but perhaps it's also our fear of, and attraction to, the unknown. This novel can be read as a stand-alone, but for a full appreciation of Adamsberg and his wacky world, I'd suggest reading the whole series: The Chalk Circle Man; Have Mercy on Us All; Seeking Whom He May Devour; Wash This Blood Clean from My Hands; This Night's Foul Work; and An Uncertain Place.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Delightful; a model of what crime fiction should be, July 19 2011
By T. Stroll - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: An Uncertain Place (Paperback)
I read a lot of crime, thriller, and suspense novels. I've read two by Fred Vargas (who's neither male nor Spanish; she's a Frenchwoman) and this one in particular was delightful. The characters are wonderfully cast, with all of their talents and skills and, on the other hand, their foibles, quirks, and eccentricities. You have, for example, the brilliant Danglard and the slow-witted Estalère, but Danglard has imperfections and Estalère shows surprising insight at one point. There are plot twists that in the hands of a lesser writer would come across as absurd. It's a testament to the quality of "Un Lieu Incertain" that one revels in suspending disbelief as the occasional extremely improbable coincidence takes place. There's great humor in this novel, as when the main protagonist, Adamsberg, speaks on the phone with an Austrian colleague in the latter's fractured French. Vargas likes to play with language (you'll see how she gives the word "abstract" an entirely new meaning) and she comes up with another word, "Plog," which in her deft care is about as malleable as "appropriate" but, unlike that dismal adjective, delightful for the reader to toy with. Vargas displays considerable humanity too, as shown by the characters' care for a struggling cat and newborn kitten. Highly recommended. (I read the novel in French and cannot vouch for the translation.)
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another gift from Vargas to her readers - Excellent!, Sep 7 2011
By L. J. Roberts - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: An Uncertain Place (Paperback)
First Sentence: Commissaire Adamsberg knew how to iron shirts. Adamsberg begins in London, attending a police conference with Sgt. Estalere and Comm. Danglard when they are directed to the gates of Highgate Cemetery. There, in front of the gate, are 17 shoes; 8 pairs and one single, removed from corpses, still containing their feet. It is a case Adamsberg is glad not to be theirs. Back in Paris, a horrific and unusual murder occurs in a suburban home. The case leads Adamsburg to Serbia, vampire legends and the possibility of losing his life. An author whose writing makes you savor particular passages, as though it was that first bit of a magnificent meal or sip of a fine wine, is a special gift. Vargas is one such author. One finds oneself reading passages aloud to others, whether they care or not, as you want to share them. Vargas is such a writer. From the opening page, Vargas' evocative descriptions immediately place you into the scene..."Since the room had windows on three sides, he spent this time moving his seat around the circular table, following the light, like a lizard on a rock." and introducing your to new concepts..."Going to London was fine by him: he would find out whether the Thames smelt of damp washing the way the Seine did, and what kind of sound the seagulls made. Perhaps they had a different call in English." Even in translation--and kudos to Siān Reynolds--Ms. Vargas voice is unique and strong. "Any experience that's too beautiful or too horrific always leaves some fragment of itself in the eyes of the people who have witnessed it." Her description of Lt. Retancourt, a large, powerful woman, is one to be envied..." "Did she know that to him she represented his tree of salvation, a tree with tough and miraculous fruit, the kind of tree you put your arms around without being able to encircle it, the kind of tree you climb up into when the mouth of hell opens?" Ms. Vargas images stay with us for a very long time after the story is done. The use of language is a pleasure to read, even to inventing one word and re-inventing another. Her droll humor brings light to the dark and her dialogue is a pleasure to our internal ear. Vargas' characters are just as unique and, you sense, beloved by the author. They are wonderful, varied, and slightly eccentric. But it's also nice to have a police procedural where much of the investigation is done by a squad working together. You don't know whether some of the characters are extremely observant and astute, or blessed with extraordinary abilities, or both. Either way, the come to life and you want to know them. Even the victim is dimensional with his back story provided and relationship with his son explained. None of the characters are simply there to fill the space. Even the dog is anthropomorphized by Amamsberg. In some ways, this book was more strictly a police procedural than others, perhaps as there was no romantic overtone to it. All the crimes are singular in their execution. The plot is smart and clever without ever being contrived. Taking Adamsberg from London to Paris to Serbia not only accentuates the mystery and the building of suspense--and she does suspense well--but adds a richness to the story. Vargas takes you down unexpected paths and includes a twist you never saw coming. She takes us on a journey; not only of locations, but of legends and superstitions, yet provides logical explanations in the end. "An Uncertain Place" was published in France in 2008. Ms. Vargas is an author you want to have write more, publish more frequently and be translated more quickly. Her books are gifts to readers and, although it sounds greedy, with each one, you want more. AN UNCERTAIN PLACE (Pol. Proc-Comm. Adamsberg-England/France/Serbia-Cont) - Ex Vargas, Fred (trans. by Siān Reynolds) - 7th in series (book 4 has not been translated) Harvill Secker, 2011, UK Trade Paperback - ISBN: 9781846554452
|
|
|