3.0 out of 5 stars
They didn't know it at the time, Mar 14 2010
Does it really matter that it's historically accurate or not? This movie was made in 1997. They only found out in 2007 that Anastasia was murdered. I still enjoy this movie very much. Even though it's not historically correct.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
anastasi dvd not recieved with in quoted time frame., Jan 12 2010
very disappointed as this video was to arrive by dec 19, 2009 and it came Jan. 8 2010. It has remained un opened now as was a christmas gift and can not be given now until my daughter's birthday in may. It was over priced but I wanted it for christmas so I decided to purchase it from vanderbilt. I will not know if it is in good working order now until May 13 2010.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Historically correct? I hope not., July 25 2005
Okay, so some people criticize this movie by saying it is not an accurate adaptation of the political and historical events going on at that time. Well, how exactly DO you intend to incorperate the (rather grim) history into a children's movie?
And that is exactly what it is: a movie for CHILDREN. It's supposed to be FUN, not teach you history. If you want to see a portrait for the political struggles in Russia at that time - go read a book about it!
Yes, the movie's characters are portrayed as black and white - the Romanovs are good, Rasputin is bad. Has it ever been different in Disney movies (yes, I do realize this is not a Disney movie)? Yes, maybe Lenin would've made a more logical bad guy, but Lenin didn't have magic powers (as far as that goes, Rasputin is the way more interesting character). Why yes, maybe they should have portrayed the hardships of revolution and the two years that the Romanov family had been held captive. Why YES, maybe they should have made Alexei a sickly boy and the whole thing utterly hopeless. It would have been more realistic and appealing to all you fine members of the politically aware adults. But no seven-year-old (as I was at the time I watched this movie) would be particularly interested in that kind of story.
As to my personal opinion, I love this movie. The songs ("Once Upon a December" is beautiful), the characters, the dialogue, the graphics, the mood, everything is just stunning. Sometimes it gets a little mushy, I suppose, as in the starting scene - but those parts are easy to overlook when viewing the wonderful whole.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No