5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ordinary Magic -- Extraordinarily Written, Jun 1 2009
By Mr. Stephen A. Bramucci "Steve Bramucci" - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Any Which Wall (Hardcover)
I'm not going to summarize Any Which Wall for you. I'm not going to describe the character arcs or unfold exactly how the plot turns. That would be something akin to handling the wings of a butterfly -- and steal some of the magic from this beautiful, timeless book.
I will tell you this: The second I opened Any Which Wall I felt dropped into a special kind of story. I knew on page one that the book held something incredible. It is the type of book that kids read on long summer afternoons with a foot dangling down from the eaves of an oak tree while drinking lemonade from a mason jar.
It is engaging and incredibly clearly rendered.
The world doesn't hang in the balance, there are no evil necromancers, no superpowers...But that doesn't mean that the book can't zip along. It does.
It is the type of middle-grade book that I hope stays in print for a hundred years-- the type Edward Eager wrote. And it holds magic-- transporting me to the basement of my grandmother's house by the sea-- where I would curl up at night as a boy discovering a love of storytelling. Where the shelves seemed endlessly stocked with the books that my mother, aunts and uncles read when they were young. Books with pen and ink illustrations, tales of adventure and heart...Books like this one.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A book that you wish wouldn't end, Jun 5 2009
By Natalie Blitt - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Any Which Wall (Hardcover)
Any Which Wall is the type of book that is worth sitting down and reviewing on Amazon. It's the type of book that is worth paying to read it, and not just waiting for it to come out at the library. It's the type of book that you want to keep on your shelf for bad days when you need to curl up in bed and be transported to a corn field in Iowa.
Any Which Wall is magical -- not just in its content but in its writing. It's lovely and sweet, and most of all smart. While intended for kids, it's equally perfect for adults. Go on and buy it, you won't be sorry you did!
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Delightful tale of magic in the everyday world, July 9 2009
By Sheila L. Beaumont - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Any Which Wall (Hardcover)
Prefaced by a quotation from Edward Eager's "Seven Day Magic," this delightful tale of "common magic" is a homage to that popular children's author of the 1950s and early '60s, who wrote "Half Magic," "Knight's Castle" and other fun stories of children finding magic in the everyday world. It's also, indirectly, a homage to early-20th-century author E. Nesbit, since Eager's own books were a homage to Nesbit, who gave us such entertaining tales as "Five Children and It" and "The Phoenix and the Carpet."
In "Any Which Wall," four children, ages 6 to 12, by keeping their eyes and imaginations open, discover a magic wall on a summer's day in an Iowa cornfield. They find out the wall will take them to other places and times, and once they figure out exactly how the magic works, it takes them to the real Camelot, where they meet Merlin, who is not what they expected. On a visit to a pioneer-day version of their own town, Quiet Falls, the children rescue an abused dog, bring her back home, bathe her and treat her injuries, and eventually find the big, lovable canine a good home in an unexpected place (and time).
There's even a hint of Narnia here, in the name of the oldest child, Susan. Fortunately, this Susan, though she is growing up, does a better job of holding on to her childhood interests than the Narnia Susan does. And we meet a wonderful librarian, named Lily, who is grown up in the practical ways that are necessary yet keeps enough of her childhood to be a kindred spirit to the children.
Adding to the magic are the excellent illustrations of LeUyen Pham. I think "Any Which Wall" will appeal both to fans of fantasy and to readers who enjoy stories about ordinary kids. And it's not just for middle-graders but also for adults who have fond memories of the books of Edward Eager and E. Nesbit.