Arming and Disarming: A History of Gun Control in Canada Hardcover – Oct 23 2012
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
‘Brown’s admirable book is an exceptionally vast, sweeping, detailed, and authoritative account of Canada’s gun experience.’ (Robert J. Spitzer Law and History Review, November 2013)
‘R. Blake Brown has produced a sweeping, thorough, insightful, and well-researched account of gun control in Canada… This book should prove useful and provocative for students and scholars of Canadian and comparative law, society, and politics.’ (William G. Merkel American Historical Review June 2014)
‘Arming and Disarming is full of fascinating and well-placed quotations from key historical figures concerning their views on gun issues… This book stands out as an important and pioneering work in the history of gun control on Canada.’(James Floros Canadian Historical Review vol 94: 03:0213)
‘Blake Brown's Arming and Disarming is a truly fine piece of scholarship, six full years in the making.’(Paull W. Bennett Chronicle Herald, January16, 2013)
‘I hugely enjoyed reading Arming and Disarming, a terrific book on a fascinating topic. R. Blake Brown imparts many fresh insights and provides important new evidence for big disputes about the rise of the regulatory state, the rights of the citizen, modern masculinity, and much else.’ (Elsbeth Heaman, Department of History and Classical Studies, McGill University)See all Product Description
Inside This Book(Learn More)
Top Customer Reviews
Brown deserves praise for pointing out the racist roots of Canadian gun laws. In times of crisis colonial governments passed laws specifically designed to disarm groups seen as suspicious or threatening. The earliest such laws targeted Aboriginal peoples, and later the resident French population. In the 18th century and 19th century authorities occasionally reacted to their fears by attempting to disarm Irish laborers, Italian immigrants, and Métis. In the 20th century, government disarmed alleged Bolsheviks and enemy aliens. During World War I, Canada disarmed or incarcerated Ukrainians, and during World War II, authorities disarmed or incarcerated Japanese, German and Italian Canadians. In British Columbia, Chinese who were born in Canada were also disarmed.
Brown aligns himself as a progressive by citing approvingly such controversial icons as Michael Bellesiles and even Michael Moore. The claims of both have now been thoroughly discredited. Ironically, progressives support the heavy hand of the state falling on groups whose threat they exaggerate, such as rural men who own guns.Read more ›
If you are looking for a scholarly tracking and analysis of gun laws in Canada, as the title would suggest, then you will be disappointed. If you are looking for analysis of those laws from the point of view of some political theory or some theory of rights, you will also be disappointed. The author's myopic anti-gun bias is unmistakeable. No opportunity is missed to reference a politician's quote or some newspaper cartoon as evidence of collective thinking at that point in time. There was no open mind at work when this book was written. There are early hints that this might be the case given that it was authored by a professor at a Toronto University and the cover begins with reference to the Ecole massacre 25 years ago. On the other hand, this was probably as objective as was possible for a researcher with that pedigree.
There are grudging references to public figures, including federal politicians, who believed that early Canadians did have the right to keep and bear arms and some of those no doubt took a bit of work to uncover but, regrettably, none of it was explored and those hints at the possibility of other, deeper significance of gun ownership by law-abiding civilians are smothered by hackneyed, bald assertions about Canada's gun culture of the sort that we have heard from our urban, elitist constituency for years.
Still, since it appears to be the only summation of Canada's gun laws, it is a useful book.Read more ›
This assessment is deeply flawed, since the people I know who hunt and/or shoot, while they work - are certainly not "working-class" but rather are from a number of backgrounds and are predominantly with higher educational degrees and hold positions in companies consistent with that. More importantly, to write a group of people off because they are "working class" harkens back to a bygone era when there was the intelligensia and the great unwashed masses. A general theme in reading through the book is the idea that if you own (or want to own) guns that you are angry (about something) and generally on the fringes of society. Even captions in the book (e.g. pg. 192) tend to serve to inflame the discussion. In this case, a photograph of a number of firearms are shown, along with the notation that one had been used in the Ecole Polytechnique shooting (the author refers to it as the "1989 Montreal Massacre"). The repetitive use of pejorative descriptors, is the best indication of the author's overall thesis.Read more ›
Most recent customer reviews
Comprehensive and interesting summary of gun control in Canada. Does not read as biased. Very readable.Published 3 months ago by Dan
this book was an easy read
the writer lays out the chronological path of the phony
gun crisis and the social re-engineering agenda of
the people in control at the... Read more
Recently winning the book of the year from the Canadian Law and Society Association this book is well researched and insightful. Read morePublished on May 18 2013 by Fred