Most helpful customer reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
Three Graphic Bios of Circumnavigators, Dec 4 2011
This review is from: Around the World (Hardcover)
Reason for Reading: I enjoy graphic biographies and while I wasn't too impressed with Matt Phelan's Storm in the Barn, thought I'd give him another go. This is the story of three late 19th century "around the world travelers". The book opens with the scene from Verne's famous book of the same name where Phileas Fogg makes his bet to travel around the world in 80 days. It was the publication of this book that inspired many real life adventurous types to set off and do the same thing. Told separately in three vignettes, the reader is introduced to the stories of three such adventurers, who each wrote a book documenting their travels. First up is Thomas Stevens a miner, who quits his job, takes up riding the new-fangled invention the bicycle and proceeds to travel around the world via bicycle (this was the penny-farthing bike at the time though he rode the American version). Next is the story of Nellie Bly, Girl Reporter who set out to beat Phileas Fogg's time and travel the world in 74 days while sending home news reports. The American public went wild for her stories. Finally, we are told the story of Joshua Slocum, retired sea captain, who fixes up a dilapidated little boat into a sea-worthy sailing ship and travels the world by sea. Each one of the stories is interesting and while having the same theme, unique from one another. Rather than being just a retelling of events, Phelan has chosen to portray each journey through the person's ultimate reasons as to why they conducted the voyage, their driving force and their eventual personal rewards. An enjoyable read. Not overly exciting, but interesting nonetheless. I can't say I'm particularly fond of Phelan's artistic style; his colours are drab and his watercolours are wishy-washy to my sensibilities, but he is a well known illustrator and obviously many others do appreciate his work. Certainly a unique topic and combination of stories.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Helping Us Understand the Nature of Adventure, May 4 2012
By DoubtingOThomas - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Around the World (Hardcover)
From [...]- Jules Verne's Around the World in 80 Days was quite the hit back in the day, particularly in the 19th century. It sparked a worldwide fascination with the idea of circumnavigating the globe and inspired a number of intrepid individuals to take on the task. Around The World tells the tale of three such explorers who took on the task: one on a bicycle- Thomas Stevens, one by himself in a tiny sloop- Captain Joshua Slocum, and one by any means possible as long as it was under 74 days- New York World Reporter Nellie Bly. Matt Phelan's beautiful, simplistic artwork takes us on the journey with these adventurous souls and puts us right there beside them. Each traveler's story is different and Phelan masterfully portrays a unique tone for all three of them, helping us understand their reasons for setting off on such an ambitious quest. We feel like we know and understand them all by story's end and, more than that, we feel like we understand better the nature of adventure. -Owen Gray
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mini Bios of Three Circumnavigators, Dec 1 2011
By Nicola Manning - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Around the World (Hardcover)
Reason for Reading: I enjoy graphic biographies and while I wasn't too impressed with Matt Phelan's Storm in the Barn, thought I'd give him another go. This is the story of three late 19th century "around the world travelers". The book opens with the scene from Verne's famous book of the same name where Phileas Fogg makes his bet to travel around the world in 80 days. It was the publication of this book that inspired many real life adventurous types to set off and do the same thing. Told separately in three vignettes, the reader is introduced to the stories of three such adventurers, who each wrote a book documenting their travels. First up is Thomas Stevens a miner, who quits his job, takes up riding the new-fangled invention the bicycle and proceeds to travel around the world via bicycle (this was the penny-farthing bike at the time, though he rode the American version). Next is the story of Nellie Bly, Girl Reporter who set out to beat Phileas Fogg's time and travel the world in 74 days while sending home news reports. The American public went wild for her stories. Finally, we are told the story of Joshua Slocum, retired sea captain, who fixes up a dilapidated little boat into a sea-worthy sailing ship and travels the world by sea. Each one of the stories is interesting and while having the same theme, unique from one another. Rather than being just a retelling of events, Phelan has chosen to portray each journey through the person's ultimate reasons as to why they conducted the voyage, their driving force and their eventual personal rewards. An enjoyable read. Not overly exciting, but interesting nonetheless. I can't say I'm particularly fond of Phelan's artistic style; his colours are drab and his watercolours are wishy-washy to my sensibilities, but he is a well known illustrator and obviously many others do appreciate his work. Certainly a unique topic and combination of stories.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Graphic Tale of Nellie Bly and 2 Other Heroes of Travel, Nov 28 2011
By David Crumm "Editor of ReadTheSpirit magazine" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Around the World (Hardcover)
The team at Candlewick Press continues to impress with their innovative approach to telling great stories for young readers, and that includes important stories we all should remember in our collective culture. So, bravo for this three-part graphic novelization of the lives of three people who circled our planet. All three are real, historical figures and the comic-book-style sequences are taken from the surviving narratives of their adventures. But, if you think you know the story of Nellie Bly circling the world, for example, this dramatic version centers on moments you may have overlooked. That's why I refer to this as a "novelization." Yes, this is history, but it's stirring drama as well. Two of the adventurers whose tales form this book are Thomas Stevens, the first person to cycle around the world, and Joshua Slocum, the first person to sail solo around the globe. What drew me to single out and praise this new Candlewick title in particular is its attention to Nellie Bly, who gets a little more than a third of the entire book. Evidence that far too many Americans are forgetting this courageous journalist is a notable slip-up on National Public Radio back in 2009, when an on-air host listed Nellie Bly among famous "serial killers." Later NPR apologized and corrected the mistake, but clearly our American memory of this crusading investigative reporter are fading. Around the World only focuses on Nellie Bly's attempt to circle the world more quickly than in Jules Verne's best-selling account. She did much more! If you are intrigued by this tough-as-nails reporter, I also highly recommend the PBS-sponsored video American Experience: Around the World in 72 Days, which also focuses on Nellie's planet-circling adventures but tells about her other exploits as well. While it is easy to dismiss Nellie as a publicity seeker, she clearly was driven to shine the light of journalism on many unfortunate corners of the human community. Even in this new graphic novel, Matt Phelan points out that she made time on Christmas Day 1889 to visit a leper colony. That was classic Nellie. This is a great gift to give young readers, but perhaps after you've enjoyed these tales yourself!
|
|
|