| ||||||||||||
Product Details
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Prodigal Apollonian,
By
This review is from: Asterios Polyp (Hardcover)
On the surface of this graphic novel, this is the story of a fifty year old academic and architect named Asterios Polyp: who lost his wife, his home, and his life's ambition. He goes to a small town where he really contemplates these things -- sometimes with the help of the highly intuitive Ursula Major and her family who take him in.However, the plot of the story is only part of its incredibly symbolic nature. Asterios Polyp is a man that embodies what the German philosopher Nietzsche would call the 'Apollonian' -- an instinct or inclination towards balance, serenity, and symmetry in life. It is no accident that Mazzucchelli draws on architecture, and Greek epic and tragedy, and even a reference to ancient Chinese burial terracotta warriors. Through his obsession with order, Asterios Polyp seeks a symmetry that never really existed inside of him, or in his life. In fact, the only two times he ever comes close to this are when he creates his theoretical architecture -- the ultimate in Plato's World of Forms because nothing he ever designed was ever built in reality -- and when he is with his wife Hana who herself is more Dionysian -- more passionate, intuitive and creative if not less confident -- than he is. The art in this graphic novel reflects this nature between the Apollonian and Dionysian: with the clear lines and angles of the Platonic Solids that make up Asterios Polyp's world, and the various shades, textures and colours of Hana's own reality. Sometimes these two worlds overlap and complement each other and sometimes make a reality that the reader can recognize, but more often than not they clash and end up looking like the exact opposite of each other. It is partially Asterios Polyp's inability to understand that his idea of perfection only exists in his mind, and that balance is not finding something that is lacking but rather its opposite and complementary number that creates this crisis in his life. In the end, he has to realize this for himself and come full circle. Some others define a classic as something that not says something about its characters and its world but also about its own form or medium -- and art itself. If these are the criteria to what a masterpiece is then Asterios Polyp is definitely one of these things. However, in addition to all of these things the text along with its protagonist attempts to explore another concept that could be described as Nietzschean or really an age-old human impulse: specifically what life's meaning is and whether or not art is in fact life. In the case of this story, I would say that it is. I also agree with Scott McCloud when he states that this is a book that you have to read more than once in order to get further meaning from it. Some academics will tell you that this is another characteristic of a classic or masterpiece. Personally, I think that this story makes me realize just how much basic shapes make up our reality and can tell us about ourselves in how we perceive them.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful,
By
This review is from: Asterios Polyp (Hardcover)
The book opens with a man watching, presumably, a pornographic movie, when his building is hit by lightning and catches fire. Such is how we meet Asterios Polyp, 50 year old architect. He grabs a few trinkets and as he rushes out the door we see he has a room full of videos, each one marked with a consecutive day of the week which appear to go on for years back. Through a series of flashbacks we follow Asterios' past and present as with the cash he takes a bus to however far it will get him, ending up in a hick town where he gets a job as a mechanic and rents a room in the house of his boss.Comments: The book is a study in self. It is hard for me to review this book critically as I have never studied philosophy and that is the main theme running through this book. The first thing to enter my mind was existentialism and after googling it, I found it fit the situation perfectly in my mind but I also so the opposite happening as well, so another google brought up the term nihilism. The amazing thing about this graphic novel is that the illustrations follow suit in a gripping display a graphic brilliance to fit the atmosphere of the pages. For characters, the book is sparse. Asterios himself is self-centered and egotistical. His Asian wife is his opposite: warm, tender and loving. Otherwise the book contains a handful of eccentric characters, who while also being wrapped in their own self manage to do so without the know-it-all, "I'm always right", attitude of Asterios. My favourite character was the garage owner's wife, Ursula Major a buxom, large, pipe smoking, luxurious blonde woman who follows all the Pagan religions and thinks she is part Indian because she was a Shaman in a past life. I haven't read anything by the author before so I didn't know what to expect and I must admit I thought it was quite weird to begin with but then things started making sense, I started understanding Asterios' character and I really enjoyed the book in the end. Speaking of the end, it's quite a shocker too. I would especially recommend this book to anyone who knows a thing or two about philosophy. You'll get a whole lot more out of it than I did but nevertheless, I took what I could from it and was pleased with the read.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great graphic novel,
By
This review is from: Asterios Polyp (Hardcover)
Guy alienates his wife, his marriage breaks up and he quits his job and gets lost for awhile. It is not a vastly original story, but the graphic sensibility and visual storytelling is quite complex and rewarding. I particularly liked the retelling of the myth of Orpheus in the subway system. The pacing and quiet sense of drama were perfect and carried the story along effortlessly as we work to unravel the mystery of how the world famous architect 'Sterio came to work as a car mechanic in small town nowhere. Really enjoyable and not even a let down, despite all of the media hype the book has received.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Want to see more reviews on this item?
|
Most recent customer reviews |
|