Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lodgian James and Jamesian Lodge, Feb 27 2011
Here is Lodge at his very best. Not quite the Lodge of our youth, doing research at the British Museum, or later deconstructing a silk cut ad, or trying to give a paper at some faraway conference. This is the mature Lodge, putting his talent as a literary critic to the reconstruction of a Jamesian universe - writing as James could have written (but this is not a pastiche) - full of tenderness, frustrations, and a crashing undeserved failure. Lodge, who seems to excel at everything, has been able to put himself under the skin of someone who experienced a terrible failure. Lodge has written a novel, in the sense that words have been put in the characters' mouth, and that some license has been taken with the reconstruction of certain scenes, but the research is impeccable, and the novelist shows the greatest respect for James and those closest to him. Even if one hasn't read James, or has forgotten it since high school, this book will still give great pleasure. By the same author, I would strongly recommend The Year of Henry James, a work of essays and literary criticism, that opens with the making of Author, Author. Here reality catches up with history when the publication of Author, Author is surrounded by truly Jamesian ironical twists. In the same book, one will find essays on "Daisy Miller", on H.G. Wells, on George Eliot, on Umberto Ecco (excellent), and other. Caution: one should not read The Year of Henry James before having read Author, Author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
"It was a dream but the dream is past.", Dec 19 2004
By M. J Leonard "MikeonAlpha" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Author Author (Hardcover)
The writer's life, the artistic temperament, and the world of the English stage are bought to life in this beautifully written, complex novel of history and ideas from author David Lodge. Author Author, while totally succeeding as an intricate recounting of Henry James's halcyon days as one of England's most famous men of letters, is also a vividly creative tale of penmanship, literary irony, the collision of values, and the transformation and courage it takes to reinvent oneself artistically. The novel also works as a sprawling account of Edwardian England, from the pastoral countryside, to the quaint seaside towns, to the gas lit and foggy London suburbs, to the stuffiness and sense of moralistic propriety of the upper-class drawing rooms. Lodge paints a portrait of a society and a culture that is undergoing profound social and artistic changes. It is amidst these changes, that author Henry James is radically trying to reinvent himself as a playwright. Framed by two deathbed scenes, the bulk of the story involves James's life-long friendship with George du Maurier, and his cautious relationship with the writer Constance Fenimore Woolson the one most influential woman in his life, who later commits suicide in Venice. James was frustrated and vexed by his dwindling book sales, and rather jealous of du Maurier who had recently achieved fame with the runaway success of his novel, Trilby. Seeking to redefine his work, James stakes his professional reputation and five years of work on a series of plays, the crowning achievement of which was to be Guy Domville. The centerpiece of the story recounts his humiliation and mortification at being savagely booed at the London premier when the lower classes nastily laugh and jeer at the silliness of the leading lady's plumed hat. From his years dining with the literary and artistic society in London to his self imposed sequester at Lamb House, Rye where he enacted his instinct for bachelorly self-preservation, Lodge paints a picture of a man who was totally devoted to a philosophical and literary life. James, through his work, wanted to refine, intensify and preserve human consciousness believing that consciousness was a type of religion. He understood that the author of fictional narratives should represent life as it is experienced in reality, by an individual consciousness, and he developed a firm faith in the superior expressiveness and verisimilitude of the limited point of view. James with his "his bushy beard, balding pate and incipient paunch," comes across as sexuality ambiguous, and his attitudes to sex "and the spilling of one's seed" were to him extremely distasteful. His views on sexuality were formed in childhood when he saw a male nude posing for a portrait and the image haunted him for days afterwards "with disturbing effects that were physical as well as mental." James also actively distances himself from Oscar Wilde and his aura of sexual scandal. And it is almost a relief when he reaches the calm waters of middle age having survived all the perils and problems, the vague longings and physical disturbances, associated with sex in early manhood. Lodge has fun with introducing us to such famous figures as Compton Mackenzie, the son of the actor- manager Edward Compton, Edith Wharton, Virginia Woolf, and Agatha Christie, who James bumps into on a cycle-ride from Torquay. Author Author is a sprawling, ambitious, and hugely entertaining novel. And Lodge, with a keen biographer's eye, doesn't hesitate to expose the complexities of James's life, involving his friendships, sexuality, and the ever changing demands of his art. Mike Leonard December 04.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
intriguing project, scintillating execution, July 20 2005
By Heather "graduate student of British literature" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Author Author (Hardcover)
This novel takes the life of Henry James as its subject and interpolates fact with fiction without losing its energy. Lodge does a wonderful job of lighting up the things that we do know about James and adding some conjecture. His rendering of the opening night of "Guy Domville"--James's flop of a play--is both comic and tragic, and would itself be worth the price of the book. Unlike Colm Toibin's "The Master" (another fictionalized biography of James), Lodge doesn't succumb to saccharine or sentimental devices to close the book, but remains sharp from beginning to end.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Novel about An Interesting Novelist, Mar 19 2005
By Jane Austin "Jane" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Author Author (Hardcover)
"Author, Author" is a well researched and entertaining novel about the novelist, Henry James. Its a must read for James'fans. Interestingly, his writings are remembered, studied and reprinted while more popular novels of his time ('best sellers') have been forgotten.( There is a lesson in that fact somewhere!) Beginning and ending with the deathbed scene of James the novel focuses on his later years and his time in England, and especially with his relationship with Constance Fenimore Woolson and George DuMaurier. At the book's end, author Lodge, specifies what details he has made up. I found this book to be a page turner.
|
|
|