3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Evocative History of the RAF's Finest Hour!, April 18 2010
By Michael OConnor "Wordsmith" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Battle of Britain: A Day-By-Day Chronicle: 10 July 1940 to 31 October 1940 (Hardcover)
Since 2010 is the 70th anniversary of the Battle of Britain, readers can expect a deluge of BoB-related titles. Patrick Bishop, who authored the similarly-themed FIGHTER BOYS, is early off the mark with this hefty release from Quereus Publishing. Though it is not the "definitive history" the flyleaf notes claim, BATTLE OF BRITAIN is an appealing, well-illustrated look at an epic event.
BATTLE OF BRITAIN, which weighs in at 392 pages, is subtitled A DAY-BY-DAY CHRONICLE, 10 JULY 1940 TO 31 OCTOBER 1940. Since the BoB story has been told many times - most notably by BATTLE OVER BRITAIN by Francis K. Mason and BATTLE OF BRITAIN THEN AND NOW - the basic facts are well-known. Where Bishop's book differs is the many first-person accounts he includes from RAF and German fighter pilots, German bomber crewmen and assorted British politicians, service personnel and civilians. The many combat reports featured in the book put the reader right in the midst of the action. Likewise the many period b&w and color photographs, illustrations, newspaper clippings, posters and memorabilia help capture the feel of those crucial months.
I had several problems with BATTLE OF BRITAIN. Bishop is inconsistent with identifying the German units involved in the air battles. Sometimes he's quite specific that "72 He111s of Kampfgeschwader 26...joined by 21 Me110 heavy fighters of Zerstorergeschwader 76" did thus-and-so. Yet, just as often, the RAF's opponents are "a gaggle of Ju87s," "dozens of Me109s," "another large formation," etc. The identify of opposing units throughout the BoB has been extensively documented so I didn't understand the inconsistency. My biggest problem was the large number of sidebars on various topics Bishop inserted throughout the book (bios of individual RAF aces, noted Luftwaffe brass, the 'Buy a Spitfire Fund,' RAF pilot training, high-octane fuel, Shadow factories and so on). While these were interesting, I felt they undercut the flow of the main text by the constant "continued on page xxx" interruptions. Much of that information could have been included in prepatory chapters before the main July-October sections.
Having said that, BATTLE OF BRITAIN has much to recommend it. The many personal reminiscences and evocative images will certainly transport the reader back to those momentous times and provide a lively, sometimes poignant you-are-there experience. Recommended.
*****
Review #975.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Really excellent informative book, April 29 2010
By P. Parkes - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Battle of Britain: A Day-By-Day Chronicle: 10 July 1940 to 31 October 1940 (Hardcover)
Well worth the price, this is a truly accurate account of a very important part of our history
4.0 out of 5 stars
A great addition to my library!, Feb 21 2011
By Fedoradude "Fedoradude" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Battle of Britain: A Day-By-Day Chronicle: 10 July 1940 to 31 October 1940 (Hardcover)
This is a very good book. The Blitz is broken down by significant periods (chapters) and they are full of narratives of battles and significant strategy developments all interlaced with personal accounts from the combatants of both sides, British citizens who endured the bombings etc. Additionally periodically in the reading, one encounters mini-biographies of key players - i.e., Keith Park, Trefford Leigh-Mallory, etc.
Be sure to not overlook the appendices in the back. Not usually a place I find interesting, exciting information worthy of spending much time. However, Appendix A gives the particular history, characteristics, specs etc on each of side's major player aircraft that were part of the Battle. Appendix B gives rich supplemental details on things like rank structures of both air forces, nationalities making up the RAF Fighter Command, battle-by-battle statistics thru November 1940, etc. As I say, the appendices are chock full of really interesting additional details.
This books make a perfect addition to my aviation/WW2 history bookshelf. I purchased this on a pre-release special purchase price. I only wish it'd been available hardcover then.