Critics suck. This album is better than people give say it is. It may not be their best work, but to anyone with any clue on what good music is should know this cd is a great one. I am a huge oasis fan and own every cd they have. I like every song they have ever written and the B-sides like Lets all belive are great. This album has what most bands dont have anymore, a guitar playing well and loud. The song I hope, I think, I know is one of the greatest songs they have written so i dont know why i hear people badmouthing this album. If i were start over and buy thier albums, this would be number 2 right after Their first one becuase that is my facorite one.