20 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
nobody home, July 27 2010
By Julia M. Walker - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Betrayed (Hardcover)
The Tanenbaums with the one-word titles are written by a ghost-writer other than Michael Gruber, he who wrote all of the two-word title Tanenbaums. Well, I've finally decided why there's only one word: because the writer wants the titles to be as mercifully forgettable as the books themselves.
As other reviewers observe, to read the first 50 pages is to read the last three novels over again. As a person who sometimes re-reads mysteries and thrillers, this isn't, in itself, the kiss of death for me. But those were three novels I'd never choose to visit again. Mr Steve Jackson (whom Tanenbaum semi-acknowledges in the fulsome credits) needs to study the work of Marsha Muller and Donna Leon to see how to convey the past events of a long-running series without boring faithful fans to tears.
But first Mr Jackson needs to re-read the early, Gruber-penned, Tanenbaums. These characters simply don't add up.
Sure, it's better than the first post-Gruber book, which radically misremembered the dramatic circumstances of Lucy Karp's birth, but it's still impossible to believe that the Lucy I watched grow up as an edgy, independent, urban demi-urchin, gifted with languages and spirituality and sheer nerve, could turn into this vanilla blob of a young woman. And it's beyond the remotest chance that either she or her mother could be pictured as follows:
"She [Marlene] and Lucy had spent many happy hours going over plans, invitations, and guest lists" for Lucy's wedding. (p 49)
No. No no no no. This isn't a 50's sitcom. Somewhere the real Marlene Ciampi is yelling obscenities, while the real Lucy has left the building entirely.
Similarly, the original Butch Karp -- painted here as a simple soul whose quest for justice is the product of a childhood spent watching John Wayne movies -- could never have uttered the banality of "Like I should care?" (p79) unless he was quoting someone else.
As for the plot. Well, if you've read any of the last 5 novels, you've seen it before (even if you don't remember it.)
In the abstract, I'd have thought that it would be relatively easy to sustain a wildly successful series. And I would have been wrong. If, like me, you miss the Karp/Ciampi clan, just reread the first 14 books.
In this book, nobody's home.
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Seriously who wrote this, July 18 2010
By Stephanie L Ebert - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Betrayed (Hardcover)
I have read all the books in the Ciampi/Karp series and enjoyed most of them alot. I feel like whoever wrote this book , I don't think it is the same person who wrote the others should have spent a little more time reading the series from the beginning. Although this was an ok read it just wasn't even close to what I have come to expect from this author. I think that anyone who has read this series from the beginning would agree. I felt like I was reading about strangers not the characters I have followed and enjoyed for years. I to think this will be my last book in this series.
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
My last Karp-Ciampi book, July 11 2010
By Ronald M. Baruch - Published on Amazon.com
This is my last Robert Tanenbaum book. If you are a reader of all previous books then you learned about them through three quarters of this book. The author dragged on and on the past story lines leaving a rushed through lack of depth to a new story line. To new readers of this series, I hope you enjoyed Betrayed. But to old timers like myself, it was a drudgery