6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Best I've yet found for teaching Biblical Hebrew, Feb 19 2008
By Rachel L. Solomin "Jewish educator and rabbi" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Biblical Hebrew for Students of Modern Israeli Hebrew (Hardcover)
As a Rabbi and adult educator, this book is the best by far I have yet found for teaching Biblical Hebrew to anyone with a background (even a relatively basic one) in Modern Hebrew. It explains clearly particular biblical forms (such as the jussive, eg.) and the differences between Biblical and Modern Hebrew. I think the text would be improved if it had an index to all of the charts. Brettler puts an unusual weight on the ability to compose/write in Biblical Hebrew, which will only be helpful for the few students for whom the mental challenge will reinforce their recognition of Biblical Hebrew forms and translation of texts. Other students will find it confusing, since they will never have a practical use for writing in Biblical, rather than Modern Hebrew. However, the structure of the book is sound and the verses for translation exercises in each chapter are well-chosen. Even American Israelis would find it useful in learning how Biblical Hebrew is different than their native tongue.
This book is not a perfect choice for students working to learn on their own, but it would serve the purpose. It is a fabulous course selection or choice for an individual working with a tutor. One must possess, in addition to this book, his/her own copy of an accurate English translation of Tanakh (the Hebrew Bible)--such as the "new" JPS. Also recommended is a good dictionary of Biblical Hebrew, such as Brown-Driver-Briggs (which is also made more accessible by separate indexes, etc.).
This book does not (at this time) come with any support materials for instructors.
Finally, I just want to let potential students of Biblical Hebrew know that I strongly recommend studying Modern Hebrew first, since learning a living language engages more learning modalities. I have found that students (Christian or Jewish) who study Biblical Hebrew first--without a strong foundation in reading and pronouncing basic Modern Hebrew--are rarely able to read confidently and accurately out-loud and sometimes find themselves embarrassed in academic settings.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
VERY USEFUL, Jun 10 2006
By Charles E. Meadows - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Biblical Hebrew for Students of Modern Israeli Hebrew (Hardcover)
This is a very good review book for those learning biblical Hebrew. Actually the title is slightly misleading - there is very little here about modern Israeli Hebrew. The overall scope is typical for an introductory grammar - perhaps similar to Pratico. The author has some very nice discussions about accentuation and syllabification - I found this to be one of the book's best features. The explanation of propretonic reduction in noun pluralization is the clearest I've found. There are numerous exercises at the end of each chapter if one likes that sort of thing.
4.0 out of 5 stars
Grammar Made Clear, Feb 9 2012
By S. Keiter - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Biblical Hebrew for Students of Modern Israeli Hebrew (Hardcover)
This text takes a challenging subject, Hebrew grammar, and conveys the concepts in clear and concise terms, with supporting illustrations for each concept. While the focus is on Biblical grammar, much of the knowledge is useful to strengthen mastery of modern Israeli Hebrew. And while this book presumes basic knowledge of modern Hebrew, one does not need to be fluent to benefit from the information in this book. The tone of the book is clear and not overly pedantic. It even includes a small number of comic illustrations of potential translation errors.
The book contains many exercises to reinforce the concepts discussed. While these exercises are very useful, my only complaint is that the book does not include the answers. Thus, there is the danger that the student studying on their own may not be correct and may be reinforcing incorrect understanding of certain concepts.