| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product)
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most helpful customer reviews
20 of 23 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Boring Beginner's Stuff,
By Sunnyside "Sunnyside" (Astoria, NY United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life (Paperback)
I'm trying to return this book right now...it's not bad, and certainly has its audience, but I'm not it. It's your basic beginner's guide to creative writing, unique for its alternately folksy and sassy tone. A certain kind of beginner will find it encouraging -- typically young and female, I suspect. It's like having your own encouraging single mum! But for anyone who's got past their own precious egos (enough to progress beyond hand-holding and back-patting, anyway) and has the minimum intellectual insight required of a would-be writer of "literary fiction" (as opposed to "genre fiction"), this book's likely to be only amusing at best. I myself cannot recommend it as being helpful to anyone writing at an advanced, pre-publication level, for which I maintain that John Gardner's "Art of Fiction" and "On Becoming A Novelist" remain the most useful of all such books, intellectually rigorous (even if it sounds elitist here and there) and spiritually uplifting for being more "formal" and "classically-minded." As it stands, "Bird by Bird" is a good enough preamble for its implicitly intended market of young female beginning writers (and sensitive "Young Werthers," for that matter). As a nice counter-weight to Gardner, I'd recommend "Self-Editing for Fiction Writers."
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not as amazing as one would expect...,
By
This review is from: Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life (Paperback)
(...)Bird by Bird was recommended to me by a dear friend as well as every other book trying to teach you how to write. So I read it. It's a little thing like a small notebook, easy. The main idea is to take one thing at a time, little by little (bird by bird).I am at a loss for words now, as even though I agree and cherish many of the truths coming out of this tiny book (not as audaciously nor blatantly laid out as the author boasts), I am furious with the writer. I dislike her profusely, for the character she comes across as is someone I would definitely not be friends with in real life. It just happened that in the timeframe I was reading this book I was using my public transit, shopping and walking time to listen to The Sum of Our Days by Isabel Allende, as well as Imperfect Birds, also by Anne Lamott. In The Sum of Our Days Anne Lamott is treated as a trusted friend, Isabel goes to her for advice at one point. In Bird by Bird Isabel is treated like a 'God forbid' kind of author, mentioned as a threat for Anne's students who would immediately copy the style and write only like that (one might wonder what type of ludicrous specimens are attending her classes). In Bird by Bird Anne is talking (if not bragging, true, trying to make a point) about how other people thought she was a good gardener because one of her main characters is tending a garden that she is passionate about. In Imperfect Birds we find the garden and the character: no, I did not think that Anne is a good gardener at the end of the book, although you could say that her mentioning of having only plastic flowers in her garden (who does that?! I think this is one of the tackiest things ever) might have altered my perception. However, in all honesty, there are a few plants mentioned here and there, as well as the way you cut them, scanty information, much less than any gardening guide would provide. The trouble she went through to get that gardening info seems quite superfluous given the result.(...) To see the rest of this review, as well as many more interesting unabridged ones go to allwords.ca.
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Maybe it's sacrilege but...,
By TheCafeWriter (Chicago, IL USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life (Paperback)
I don't really care for this book. With all the hyperbole about it, I really expected it to be the Holy Grail of inspirational writing books.Instead, it's very heavily laden with metaphors and similes where writing and related topics are compared to all manner of things, and a lot of self-indulgent autobiography that I found more off-putting than inspiring. In just one short chapter on "giving" she presents these: * "shot my literary creative wad every day" I found that kind of style tedious after a while. I've tried repeatedly to get through this book - even getting it on tape (and the author reads the entire thing in a monotone). The overall tone is depressing (unless you really want to hear about cancer and cocaine abuse), and the points can be frustratingly contradictory. For example, she exhorts on writing your truth and pain, but at the same time quotes an editor who told her "you assume everything that's happened to you is interesting." This is like telling new writers to dig deeply within their own memories/experiences and write about them honestly, and then chiding them for writing "what really happened." I only found a couple of useful tidbits, but with so many other books on this subject that say the same things more concisely and directly, this one just isn't worth it. If you really want to read it, check it out of the library instead.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Want to see more reviews on this item?
|
Most recent customer reviews |
|