Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Intelligent, engrossing courtroom drama, Feb 1 2012
Based on a real life incident of Australian soldiers charged with murder -- for political reasons-- during the Boer war. Echoes of Kubrick's "Paths of Glory", but the morality here is more grey. These men have indeed done awful things, but only as part of a war full of awful things. Thus, while your heart is with the protagonists, there are moments you question them almost as much as the Kangaroo court they face. The acting is excellent throughout, and what was originally a play has been opened up just enough so as not to feel stagey, without feeling forced. Some of the moral complexities could have been explored with more depth, and there is a slightly disturbing suggestion of making "I was just following orders" a viable defense for war atrocities, but I'd much rather question an intelligent, challenging picture"s point of view, then not be challenged at all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good, Mar 6 2002
This review is from: Breaker Morant (Widescreen) (DVD)
This is a film about a trial of three Australians who were accussed of shooting Boer prisoners and also the murder of a minister. The trial is interspersed with flashback scenes of the actual conflict. In short the Boers after some initial successes were defeated by the more numerous British forces. They however did not accept defeat and mounted groups of Boer farmers continued to fight a guerilla war. The Boer war was notable for a number of things one being the invention of concentration camps. The British locked up the wives and children of the Boers so that they could not be supplied while carrying out raids. Some 20,000 women and children are said to have died in the camps. This film centres on some Australian troops who followed orders to shoot captured Boer commandoes. One of them Breaker Morant was a noted poet of the time who in Australia had contributed to the Bullutein Magazine for some time. He volunteered with an Australian unit to fight in the war. The film is largely about the hypcrosy of the British High Command who were willing to order the killing of prisoners and then to deny it when their actions in South Africa were causing a stink. Some territorials were put on trial to play the role of sacraficial victims. The problem with most Australian films is that they have poor scripts. Great photography and composition is no substitute for a tight script. The virtue of this film is that it is one of the best scripted Australian films released. It is also noteworthy as a film which is critcal of the Imperial tradition. The cast is very good with Edward Woodwood, Brian Brown and Jack Thompson. One of the better Australian films made.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Aussie rules!, Feb 6 2009
What a wonderfully made movie. A great period piece. Spectacular performances through out make you feel like you are right there in the middle of the action. This movie makes you think that killing might be justified and then maybe not? Once again the Stuffy British attitude during this period is brought to task and exposed as the reason for many deaths and injustices. Ultimately a stimulating ride well worth the 2 hours. Bryan Brown and Edward Woodward were born for these roles. This movie helped launch almost everyone involved into even bigger productions.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|