3.0 out of 5 stars
Shiploads of authenticity, April 11 2004
Even authenticity can be overdone, and those of us who don't know our backstay from our starboard leech may at times feel drowned by the ocean of detail Nelson incorporates into his story. There is however an excellent labeled diagram of a brig of war, to help the reader. The author's storytelling skills are first rate, his handling of dialogue less good. Other reviewers have drawn attention to the anachronous 'okay'. What jarred with me was the utterly unconvincing vernacular of the British seamen.
There is no great theme, message or purpose to the story. It is a straightforward, action-stuffed nautical adventure yarn. The action is excitingly and memorably handled. It is a limited theatre of action though, for there is not much to do except shipwreck, mutiny and collide with another vessel. If you a fan of the genre, your list is probably headed by Forester and O'Brian. What better name than 'Nelson' to add to that list?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Great American Nautical Saga, Oct 20 2003
By A Customer
Now is the time for all good sailors, whether on board ship or in their armchairs, to get behind the greatest living nautical novelist, James L. Nelson, and shout "Hold firm!" Sure I stiffened my upper lip with Hornblower, and sure I waded happily through Patrick O'Brian's eclectic and sometimes prissy "Jane Austen" tales of the sea. I've sailed with Dewey Lambden and Alexander Kent and a host of others. But this is the AMERICAN side of things, blast it! And no one, I'm telling you, no one, does it better than James L. Nelson! Doing my research, I've discovered that Nelson has been published in Merry Olde England, and translated into several languages - but he was ours first!
Nelson has evidently (judging from biographical material available) done some powerful sailing himself, but anyone can study up on nautical terms and history. What sets Nelson apart is his peculiar Americaness and with it the contradictory impulses that American men at war have struggled with since the Revolution (the subject by the way, of this book). Sure they might be sailors, and sure they might be under the command of the captain and his officers, but secretly (and sometimes not so secretly) every American sailor is the master of his fate and the captain of his soul. The English could rule the waves for a couple of centuries by pluck, undeniable courage, and unrelenting organization, but the Americans were bound to kick dust in their British cousins' faces with the sort of individualism that would characterize so many American involved battles, at sea as well as on land.
Okay, end of tirade. This is the beginning. Here are the first shock waves of the American Revolution, the nautical war so very seldom chronicled. Here is Isaac Biddlecomb, merchant, smuggler, and hell under sail! Here is his second in command, Rumstick, who cares about the Colonial cause as Biddlecomb does not. If you love to imagine the awful thunder, the cries and the bellowing commands, the shudder of ship ramming ship, there is no better place to begin than the pages of this book. And neither is it blood and thunder only, for Nelson can craft characters that make you laugh and make you care, and sail his theme of rough individuality, courage, and ultimate sacrifice as few other authors in this genre can do.
Best of all, this is only the first in a series, and several series, and Nelson just gets better and better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Packs a punch, Dec 10 2002
Nelson might get a bad rep for sticking too much action in a short space, but I found this first book to be outstanding. He knows his seamanship and how to write a villain that is completely despicable. I'm excited to find an American writer attempting to write an American Hornblower!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No