Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hail Caesar, July 24 2006
This review is from: CAESAR Politician and Statesman (Paperback)
Who would have thought Roman politics could be exciting? Fights in the senate, riots in the streets...Great stuff. This is a study of Caesar's political career, but you still get a feel for his personality, too. It is thorough and scholarly, but still very readable. It didn't bore me at all, although I'm a little bit in love with Caesar, so anything about him interests me. However, if you want to know more about his life and/or military career, you're better off with another book. My only complaint is the untranslated Latin quotes in the footnotes. I do have a dictionary, but it's annoying having to look everything up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating.... Republic scholars must read!, Feb 20 2004
This review is from: CAESAR Politician and Statesman (Paperback)
If you are a student of the final years of the Roman Republic or Julius Caesar, this book is for you. I first read Anthony Everitt's Cicero (which I liked) and it's brief discussions of Caesar were enough to pique my interest in further study of Caesar. After researching a bit, Gelzer's biography seemed to be the most lauded- and having read it- rightly so. The level of detail in this book is incredible. There are hundreds of footnotes indicating sources and often containing quotes in their original language which is as often Greek as it is Latin. Gelzer really shows us the genius and abilities of this most fascinating man- perhaps the boldest, most brilliant military commander in history- not to mention an equally talented politician! Caesar deserves our attention.
Do yourself a favor. If you can handle great detail and really want to know Caesar and his times, buy this book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The classic biography of Caesar, Mar 9 2003
This review is from: CAESAR Politician and Statesman (Paperback)
In writing a Web biography of Julius Caesar, I read dozens of books trying to explain this chameleon man, probably the most famous Roman who ever lived. And after it all, I came back to this as my firm choice as THE book to read if you want a comprehensive, scholarly, yet still fascinating excavation of everything we truly know about Caesar. Gelzer's book is a classic on everyone's list. First published in German in 1921, Gelzer labored and rewrote it over half a century, reading and rethinking all the time. It was finally translated into English in the 1960's. As he modestly concludes, "Much has been written about Caesar. The appearance of despotic rulers [Stalin, Hitler] of quite a different stamp has not always been favourable to the judgment passed on him. A fresh study of the sources has, on the whole, convinced me of the correctness of my interpretation." Gelzer makes those sources lucid, explaining contradictions, noting where a history is political rather than factual, smoothing out inconsistencies and providing copious notes for the reader who wants to learn more. There is a clarity and precision to his writing that is oddly restful, yet continually interesting, for which we must thank the readable translation by Peter Needham. In recent years, it has become fashionable to dismiss Caesar as a power-hungry megalomaniac, to psychoanlyze him, to portray him from every vantage point; but no one can deny his genius. Gelzer, unlike some modern biographers of Caesar, never strays from the facts; his thoughtful and precise narrative of every scintilla of truth remaining to us, takes you as close to the man as you are ever likely to get. About the true nature of Julius Caesar, every thinking reader must make up his own mind. Gelzer will give you the best tools to do so, while painting an unforgettable portrait of the failing Roman Republic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|