Canada in Afghanistan: The War So Far Hardcover – Feb 28 2007
|New from||Used from|
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
It has been said that Canada is a country with too much geography and too little history. Afghanistan has too much of both. As the war escalates in Afghanistan, more Canadians are asking what we are doing there. For a country that has specialized in peacekeeping, this war is a shock ― one that we have not yet comprehended. As the casualties mount, Canadians will want to know why we are there.
Canada in Afghanistan introduces readers to Afghans and their culture, gives historical background from our involvement since 9/11, and covers operations casualties and the results. Also included is an examination of a new strategic experiment ― the provincial reconstruction team and the technological advances used in this war. Cautionary predictions conclude the book. Canada in Afghanistan is an introduction to what is happening in Afghanistan and what we can expect through 2009.
About the Author
With Canada in Afghanistan, well-known aviation author Peter Pigott has changed literary gears. Embedded with Canadian Forces in Kandahar, Pigott traces Afghanistan's ancient history to present-day media sound bites, meticulously incorporating Canadian involvement in the three Ds: defence, development, and diplomacy. Pigott lives in Ottawa.
Inside This Book(Learn More)
Top Customer Reviews
Ch 1 covers Afghan history
Ch 2 covers the build up of Cdn military involvement as well as the debut of aid and development programs.
Ch 3 covers aid and development projects as well as Info Ops.
Ch 4 covers equipment procurement and the political issues surrounding contracts etc.
My analysis of the book is as follows in point form:
Lots of personal accounts, but mostly from service and support personnel working out of Kandahar Airfield.
A few too many banal details, such as describing the entertainers and their acts presented for a CANCON show.
Numerous historical examples from Afghan, British, Canadian history. Some of which are not pertinent to the subject.
Omits accounts of combat operations (except for the battle of Maywand during the second Anglo-Afghan war). This omission is odd because Pigott states that it is the rural areas that are the life blood of afghan society and culture. There is no mention that it was the battles in the Panjawai-Zhari districts in late summer 2004 that secured these rural areas allowing aid and development projects to be carried out in the first place.
A lot of aid and development history. Covers successful aid and development projects not covered by the media, such as establishing an ammunition depot at Shirzai, but Pigott overlooked important shortcomings, such as failure to establish steady pay for the Afghan police.
Not much analysis or developed theories as to the outcome of Canada's role in Afghanistan.
As for covering Canada's combat role in what is primarily a combat mission, this book has numerous shortcomings.
This book is better suited for students, civilians interested in aid and development and looking to get a better overall situational awareness of Canada's humanitarian contributions to Afghanistan.