Canadian Idol Greatest Moments [Compilation]

1. REFLECTION (AUDREY DE MONTIGNY): (3/5) The album starts out extremely weak with this song choice. I have no idea what happened in the studio with this one, but Audrey sounded much, much better on the show (I should know, I voted for her that night!). I don't mind her accent (French), but it comes through a bit too stong on this track, and I think the producers may have told her to so, since it didn't shine through nearly as much when she performed 'Reflection' on the show. Needless to say, I was very dissappointed upon hearing this track, seeing as Audrey was one of my favorite competitors.

2. DON'T LET THE SUN GO DOWN ON ME (TYLER HAMILTON): (5/5) This is definitely an amazing track. Tyler has a wonderful voice, and I was very dissappointed to see him go so soon in the show. This was definitely his best performance, and definitely a perfect choice for his contribution to the album.

3. I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU (CANDIDA CLAUSERI): (5/5) This was the song that got Candida into the top 11. Unfortunatly, it seems this was the only song she could sing well. Thankfully, we don't have to listen to her sing any other tracks on the album, and this song is so wonderfully sung, it doesn't matter how badly she sings anything else.

4. COME AWAY WITH ME (KAREN LEE BATTEN): (4/5) I'll be honest here, I really don't like this song. I mean, I really can't stand it. Fortunatly Karen Lee has such an excellent voice, I'm willing to put my prejudice for the song aside to rate this track. Karen Lee was one of my favorite competitors, and though I wish they had put her version of 'Black Velvet' on this album, she still sounds so amazing she definitely deserves the four stars.

5. AT THIS MOMENT (GARY BEALS): (4/5) I wasn't a huge fan of Gary, and I really don't think he deserved to come in second place, but I have to give him credit with this song. His voice sounds wonderful, and his emotion really shines through. This was definitely the best choice of song for him.

6. SOMETIMES WHEN WE TOUCH (MIKEY BUSTOS): (1/5) If I could give this song a negative rating I would. Mikey was my least favorite competitor in the entire competition. The only song he ever sounded good singing was the one he sang during his audition. If they had put that song on instead of this, it would have been much better. His voice is too breathey and he sounds as though he is dying. This really is a horrible track.

7. TOWER OF SONG (JENNY GEAR): (4/5) I didn't like Jenny Gear on the show. She seemed nice enough, but I really didn't like her voice, or her... stage presence. This song was quite a happy surprise for me though. I'm not sure what the producers did, but she really sounds quite good on this track. Maybe she sounds better whan you don't have to look at her facial expressions during her performances.

8. SUPERSTAR (BILLY KLIPPERT): (5/5) Billy was probably one of my top two favorites on the show. He has an amazing voice, and he should have made it further than Gary. This song is amazing, but I really wish they would have waited until the show was complete to make this album, then Billy could have sang 'Levon.'

9. YOUR SMILING FACE (RICHIE WILCOX): (2/5) There is something wrong with this song. I don't even know how to describe it. How did Richie make it through to the top 11 singing this? Honestly, this song is horrible, it's painful to listen to. It's not as bad as Mikey's because, whereas Mikey has a bad voice, Richie's song choice was horrible, not so much his voice.

10. JUST THE WAY YOU ARE (RYAN MALCOLM): (4/5) Of course, now we've come to Ryan's song. I would have liked for Ryan to sing 'Believe,' but he couldn't, of course, because of when the album came out. This is still a good track though. I don't much care for the song, but I love Ryan's voice, and am extremely glad that he won the competition.

11. TRY IT ON MY OWN (TOYA ALEXIS): (5/5) Of course, don't they always save the best for last? Toya was arguably the best singer on the show, and deserved to have gone so much further than she did. This song is amazing. I really mean it, this is definitely the best track on the album, and probably one of the best versions I've ever heard of 'Try It On My Own.' I expect big things from Toya, she really deserves it.