4.0 out of 5 stars
classic, May 15 2009
Cimmarron, academy award winner for best picture. It is best viewed with the mindset of early talkies. The characters and acting are stilted and plastic. The movie is a lot of fun, but, with today's jaded audience, may be seen as corny. I enjoyed it in its historical aspect and as an example of early epic cinema
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
epic 1930 Western (3.5/5), Oct 20 2007
Cimarron traces the early history of Oklahoma,starting with the land
rush in 1899.from there it spans forty years in the development of that
land into an eventual American state and the advances of technology
that came with it.the story itself is an epic tale,so its focus is
pretty broad.this sort of makes it a bit impersonal at times.it starts
off slow,but somewhere along the lines it picks up and becomes somewhat
compelling.i also found it interesting how people behaved back in that
time,at least according to the movie.it does feel a bit like a silent
movie at times.some of the acting feels over exaggerated.that sort of
makes sense,since talking pictures had just recently replaced silent
films as the movie medium.so,many of the actors would have been used to
acing in silent pictures.nevertheless,i still enjoyed it,for the most
part.for me,Cimarron is a 3.5/5
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A profound old movie, April 30 2004
This review is from: Cimarron (VHS Tape)
You know, I have to agree with Mr. Erdelac - the movie is progressive for its time. For those of you who judge a movie by the degree to which it beats a political or social drum, there is much here to admire.
But there is more. There is something artistic. There is an odd balance between melodrama and something really substantial, something actually edifying to the viewer. I think a large part of why this movie doesn't descend into the sludge of cinematic slop is because the characters are all flawed, and in those flaws the viewer cannot help but recognize a touch of human frailty. Every individual in this movie is at times ridiculous and at other times supremely dignified. This, I believe, gives it a certain depth.
The characters in any great movie MUST be larger than life if the piece is to avoid being either a documentary or a soap opera. But here the larger than life characters seem firmly rooted in the earth, which brings them closer to us. I like that.
Overall, I think the sensitive viewer will find in this movie much that is both emotionally and philosophically stimulating, if he/she is willing to look past the inevitable veneer of 74 years. I personally consider it a particularly moving and thought-provoking cinematic experience.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No