From Publishers Weekly
This first book in the projected Tales of the Nine Charms trilogy is unoriginal and scattered in its focus, a B-list choice for fantasy readers. The beginning is disorienting: three separate child protagonists pursue seemingly unrelated adventures. Only in mid-novel do they find themselves united in a fight against "The Dark One" who threatens the magical world of Sunnebeam--but the exact nature of the threat remains murky even at the close of the book ("The dark will rise again," says a villain, in one of several obvious echoes of Susan Cooper's classic The Dark Is Rising fantasy sequence). Smart-mouth Walker, an American, has been called into Sunnebeam to be "the Bearer," while Gypsy girl Aurora, gifted with second sight, is "the Protector." And smart but sexist Niko, formerly in training to become a kind of peaceful warrior, finds himself "the Chooser." Farber, formerly a children's book editor, and Sansevere, who collaborated with Mercer Mayer on children's computer programs, leave readers hanging--but their world of wise gypsies, sage warriors and magic charms may not be wondrous enough to bring any but the most ardent fantasy buffs back to learn the ending. Ages 8-12. (Jan.)
Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 6-9-The first in a new fantasy trilogy, this book begins in our world but moves quickly to a parallel one. Walker Crane is on a school field trip when he falls into a fountain and finds himself in a strange place. His fate soon becomes entangled with that of two other young people who inhabit this world: Niko, a warrior in training, and Aurora, a Gypsy girl with unusual though untapped powers. Together these three become Bearer, Chooser, and Protector in a dramatic saga that pits the Lords of Time against the dark. Like Susan Cooper's "Dark Is Rising" series (McElderry), this title contains prophetic, cryptic rhymes and a quest for symbolic objects, in this case nine jeweled charms. The foes of the light are malevolent men served by merciless, cruel soldiers called Dragons. The plot twists and turns its way through numerous exciting but sometimes confusing adventures. Walker finds himself perilously caught in the midst of some Dragons in training. Aurora meets otherworldly spirits who may or may not wish her well. And Niko learns that his master has taught him well how to fight. The elements of high fantasy are here but the story never quite gels. Characters lack depth and the plot elements have little cohesiveness. Events occur, and readers will just have to trust that the pieces of the puzzle will eventually come together.
Bruce Anne Shook, Mendenhall Middle School, Greensboro, NC Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.