7 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Incorrect information, Nov 8 2007
By Joseph Humber "Catwoman" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Civil War Roster of Davidson County, North Carolina: Biographies of 1,996 Men Before, During and After the Conflict (Hardcover)
This book was very badly researched. Julius C. Loftin was my great grandfather. The author has part of the information correct, his birth place, his Civil War Record, the name of my great grandmother and where they were married. However, he listed his birthday wrong, ALL of his children wrong (I should know who my grandfather and father were!), his death date wrong and the place that he died and is buried wrong.
I contacted the publisher about this mistake and they said that they would pass the information on to the author. However, I have never heard a word from the publisher again or from the author.
I was so livid with rage at this mistake that I did not bother with the rest of the book even though many of my ancestors were listed in it.
Save your money on this one. You can get the book through interlibrary loan if you just must see it, but please keep in mind it was done by a 27 year old who probably has very little interest in YOUR history.
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Haphazard research, Mar 21 2011
By Leslie Bucher - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Civil War Roster of Davidson County, North Carolina: Biographies of 1,996 Men Before, During and After the Conflict (Hardcover)
As stated in prior reviews the research for this book was haphazard at best. Many of Mr Wafford's biographies have incorrect or incomplete family data, or the families of similarly named soldiers were intermingled. A simple review of census records might have straightened out some of the misinformation.
Although much of the biographical information is suspect, the book is helpful as a research tool. Rather than going to each regiment and company roster to compile a list of Davidson County Civil War soldiers, they are already listed. Individual data can then be cross referenced with Civil War records, censuses, marriage records, cemetery surveys, etc.
1 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Research issues, April 25 2010
By Barry Miller - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Civil War Roster of Davidson County, North Carolina: Biographies of 1,996 Men Before, During and After the Conflict (Hardcover)
I commend Mr. Watford for his effort, but he seems to have gotten mixed up on his facts. My ancestor too, is misrepresented. Watford records him as having never married (something his numerous descendants find either vexing or humorous) and attending a college he did not attend. I think that data got garbled in his notes, and that the bio he gives probably connects to someone else. There's likely no demand, but a corrected second edition would keep a lot of family researchers from going off base.