From School Library Journal
Grade 8 Up–Cultures and nationalities clash in this complicated novel set in the 1750s. The Acadians hate the English who occupy their land; people in the Massachusetts colony hate the Acadians; and just about everyone hates the Native American tribes. Claire is trying to hold tight to her family, her land, and her life. A prologue recounts a shipwreck and foreshadows the tragedies awaiting the 15-year-old and her Acadian family. In part one, despite mounting tensions, Claire builds a secret relationship with Sam, one of the British soldiers, but their loyalties are put to the test when the soldiers imprison all of the men in her village. Claire and the rest of the women are deported when the English complete their takeover of Acadia. Part two, after the shipwreck, describes the hardships Claire faces as an indentured servant in the Massachusetts colony. She decides to try to make her way back to Canada with the help of a Mohawk Indian. They fight a battalion of English soldiers along the way, a group that coincidentally includes Sam. An epilogue ties everything together. The novel covers a lot of complex history and is a commentary on the atrocities that happen when one nation or group of people declares superiority over another. The characters experience one bad thing after another, but the story ends on a hopeful note. Readers with a little knowledge of colonial history may have an easier time understanding the events, but others may be educated by these slices of history that are not often covered in traditional social-studies classes.–Cheri Dobbs, Detroit Country Day Middle School, Beverly Hills, MI
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Gr. 7-10. "I came to the horrible realization that I really was in a strange, strange land on the other side of the sea. I knew for the first time that I should never see my homeland again." Claire Richard has already survived the death of her parents, deportation from her beloved Acadian village, and a violent storm at sea. British and French forces are at large in 1755, but she is determined to return to Acadia with her remaining sister and brother. She also seeks her true love, Sam, a reluctant British soldier. Using traditional elements of the historical novel, Kositsky puts a human face on the expulsion of the Acadians from what is now Nova Scotia. Plenty of action and the determination of the strong female heroine move the story swiftly along, but the subject matter and style are best suited to curricular use or to recreational readers with a special interest in Canadian history. A very short historical note concludes. Cindy Welch
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Review
As I began to read award-winning poet and children's author, Lynne Kositsky's Claire by Moonlight, a story set in 1755, during the expulsion of the Acadian people from Nova Scotia, I was reminded how many of their descendants had resettled in Louisiana, an American state Hurricane Katrina had just devastated. Once again people had to leave their homes with nothing but their clothes on their backs, and find, however temporarily, a new place to live.
This ninth novel by Kositsky, an author who has received many awards and honors for her writings (Society of School Librarians Honor Book, and the Raven Award among others), is a touching dramatisation of one teenage girl's ordeal when the British take over her family's land and evacuate Grand PrT, the village where her roots are. Claire Richard is a pretty and feisty fifteen-year-old, a romantic who has her eye on a young British soldier named Sam Douglass. Throughout Claire's peripatetic story, she retains a strong sense of her identity, and often repeats in her diary that she is not French from France, as some might think, but Acadian French, which is very different. She doesn't speak English, but this doesn't hinder communication with the green-eyed Sam, who is part French and conflicted in his loyalties. Claire falls for this unlikely suitor, after he risks his life to save her cat, Chou-Chou, from a fire that destroys the family's farm.
Kositsky is adept and confident at portraying teenage girls, for she has done so in several other books, including Rachel : A Mighty Big Imagining in the popular Our Canadian Girl Series. Claire Richard is portrayed as mature for her age, as she has had to be a parent to her own mother, who is flirtatious with men, and generally incapable of taking care of her younger children, Marie-Joseph, and Jean, who is deaf and blind. Claire has taken up this role, and can't look to her father for help as he is weak-willed, and eventually disappears when the British soldiers invade the village. Jacques, her older brother, helps with the farm, and after the fire, fights the British. He warns Claire against his enemy, Sam Douglass.
What troubles Claire is the possibility that Sam Douglass is a spy. The novel's theme, which is about trust and faith, is well developed. Claire is a devout Catholic girl, who is grateful to have her precious amethyst rosary when she escapes the village with her sister and brother. But she isn't perfect; she steals paper and a pen, when she's living in the house of the Dunns, a rich family in Massachusetts who take her in as a servant. As a child in Grand-PrT, Claire had the privilege to be educated by the village priest, and writing down her thoughts in a journal is a vital way for her to cope through the numerous crises that mar her life.
Although she knows it is wrong to steal, her need to write is an impulse too strong to repress. This humanity defines Claire throughout the novel, and teenage girls will be able to sympathize with her passionate nature. Even though she is courted by the rich young man Jacob, who saved her from a sinking ship, and took her to his sister's home in Massachusetts, she continues to long to be reunited with Sam Douglass, and find out if he is sincere in his love for her.
Kosistsky explains in her Afterword that she has simplified the historical facts about the Acadian expulsion from Canada to the United States to make the story easier to read. The author hopes that this vivid novel will stimulate young people to learn more about Acadia and Canadian history in general.
Anne Cimon (Books in Canada)
-- Books in Canada
This ninth novel by Kositsky, an author who has received many awards and honors for her writings (Society of School Librarians Honor Book, and the Raven Award among others), is a touching dramatisation of one teenage girl's ordeal when the British take over her family's land and evacuate Grand PrT, the village where her roots are. Claire Richard is a pretty and feisty fifteen-year-old, a romantic who has her eye on a young British soldier named Sam Douglass. Throughout Claire's peripatetic story, she retains a strong sense of her identity, and often repeats in her diary that she is not French from France, as some might think, but Acadian French, which is very different. She doesn't speak English, but this doesn't hinder communication with the green-eyed Sam, who is part French and conflicted in his loyalties. Claire falls for this unlikely suitor, after he risks his life to save her cat, Chou-Chou, from a fire that destroys the family's farm.
Kositsky is adept and confident at portraying teenage girls, for she has done so in several other books, including Rachel : A Mighty Big Imagining in the popular Our Canadian Girl Series. Claire Richard is portrayed as mature for her age, as she has had to be a parent to her own mother, who is flirtatious with men, and generally incapable of taking care of her younger children, Marie-Joseph, and Jean, who is deaf and blind. Claire has taken up this role, and can't look to her father for help as he is weak-willed, and eventually disappears when the British soldiers invade the village. Jacques, her older brother, helps with the farm, and after the fire, fights the British. He warns Claire against his enemy, Sam Douglass.
What troubles Claire is the possibility that Sam Douglass is a spy. The novel's theme, which is about trust and faith, is well developed. Claire is a devout Catholic girl, who is grateful to have her precious amethyst rosary when she escapes the village with her sister and brother. But she isn't perfect; she steals paper and a pen, when she's living in the house of the Dunns, a rich family in Massachusetts who take her in as a servant. As a child in Grand-PrT, Claire had the privilege to be educated by the village priest, and writing down her thoughts in a journal is a vital way for her to cope through the numerous crises that mar her life.
Although she knows it is wrong to steal, her need to write is an impulse too strong to repress. This humanity defines Claire throughout the novel, and teenage girls will be able to sympathize with her passionate nature. Even though she is courted by the rich young man Jacob, who saved her from a sinking ship, and took her to his sister's home in Massachusetts, she continues to long to be reunited with Sam Douglass, and find out if he is sincere in his love for her.
Kosistsky explains in her Afterword that she has simplified the historical facts about the Acadian expulsion from Canada to the United States to make the story easier to read. The author hopes that this vivid novel will stimulate young people to learn more about Acadia and Canadian history in general.
Anne Cimon (Books in Canada)
-- Books in Canada
Book Description
Claire’s future should be simple and predictable and include all the normal expectations of a young Acadian woman. But her life is far from straightforward. Her mother’s mental illness is a blot on the family name and Claire feels the brunt of it keenly. Her father, long sickened by his wife’s behavior, barely finds the energy to fend for his ever-growing family. Claire’s brother, Jacques, is increasingly angry and suspicious of the British soldiers who seem to take an unnatural interest in the family’s daily routine. Grandmère, well she is Grandmère – always hard to please, never capable of a single word of praise, no matter how hard Claire works to provide for all of them.
And then there is Sam Douglass, handsome in his red coat and always paying attention to her. What danger does she court just by talking to him? Somehow Claire must make sense of it all before her home in Grand-Pré is changed forever. There are traitors about but who are they? Is Sam one? Is Jacques? Most terrifying of all, is she?
Lynne Kositsky paints a vivid portrait of the land, the Acadians, and a tragic chapter in history. Claire by Moonlight traces the journey of one girl, facing insurmountable odds, who will forever remain haunted by the ghosts of those she loved.
And then there is Sam Douglass, handsome in his red coat and always paying attention to her. What danger does she court just by talking to him? Somehow Claire must make sense of it all before her home in Grand-Pré is changed forever. There are traitors about but who are they? Is Sam one? Is Jacques? Most terrifying of all, is she?
Lynne Kositsky paints a vivid portrait of the land, the Acadians, and a tragic chapter in history. Claire by Moonlight traces the journey of one girl, facing insurmountable odds, who will forever remain haunted by the ghosts of those she loved.
About the Author
Lynne Kositsky is an award-winning Canadian poet and author who lives in Toronto with her husband, son, and two shelties. A teacher most of her life, Lynne has taught at the middle, secondary, and university levels, but resigned six years ago to pursue writing children’s and young adult novels full time. She has been awarded the E. J. Pratt Medal in poetry as well as an international White Raven Award, given by the International Youth Library in Munich to books that “contribute to an international understanding of a culture and people.” Claire by Moonlight is Lynne Kositsky’s ninth novel.
