5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
An enlightened view on American health reform history, Nov 18 2004
By Lady Murasaki - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Clean Living Movements: American Cycles of Health Reform (Paperback)
There are several books published that aim to describe the history of public health in America. These books are often filled with dates and facts and struggle to separate themselves from books on the history of medicine. Ruth Clifford Engs' "Clean Living Movements", while a book on the history of public health, is not one of those books.
Engs describes the history of public health in the United States clearly and concisely as a series of 3 distinct health reform cycles (1830 - 1860, 1880 - 1920, and 1970 - 2005). Each cycle has ebbed and flowed, and each cycle has followed the same order of stages: moral suasion, coercion, backlash, and complacency. Engs gives the reader a well-organized outline of each "clean living movement" with enough supporting facts on the religious, political, technological, economic, cultural, and demographic changes surrounding each cycle that influenced views on health and health reform, making it unique (and sometimes similar) to the other cycles. Some topics she discusses are smoking, alcohol and drug consumption, exercise, eugenics, and sexuality. She also describes prominent health reformers in each cycle in detail.
This is my favorite book on public health history to date, as it is very easy to read and Engs strongly and clearly makes her case of the cyclical nature of health reform. It is well-organized, simply written, and well-researched. This text is quite sociological, historical, and anthropological, making it accessible to diverse readers, and includes an exhaustive list of references.