- Format: NTSC, Import
- Language: English
- Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
- Number of discs: 1
- MPAA Rating:
- Studio: Vidmark / Trimark
- Release Date: Nov 16 2001
- Average Customer Review: 4.6 out of 5 stars See all reviews (102 customer reviews)
- ASIN: B00005QCW8
Product Details
|
Tag this product(What's this?)Think of a tag as a keyword or label you consider is strongly related to this product.
Tags will help all customers organize and find favorite items. |
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent for its time,
By
This review is from: Nine Inch Nails: Closure (VHS Tape)
First, let me clear a couple of things up: this VHS does NOT contain the Broken movie; it was too graphic to release commercially, although some claim to have a master copy of it on eBay or something. Also, to people complaining about the quality of the footage on tape 1, know this; this wasn't meant to be a concert experience, that's what And All That Could Have Been was for. This tape is simply documentary footage that has no more or less a fitting film quality than you would see on a documentary on MTV or something. Yes, that's what I compare it to. There's even a disclaimer at the beginning of the tape explain that conditions weren't ideal in this setting; notice that most if not all of the live performances are set in small second-rate stadiums where not even the band has much room to move around on...something comparable to where a garage band would play or something, so it's a given that it won't be the best quality.Now, with that being said, why don't I talk about the video itself? It's only been 6 hours since I recieved it and already I fell in love with it! The fan footage before we see Trent and the gang was to be expected for this kind of documentary, and what would it have been without it? I'll talk about the backstage footage only since that was most interesting. It surprised me a bit to see Trent smile the times that he did since the only other previous times I'd seen him smile were in a post-The Fragile photo and in his interview with Kurt Loder before the 1999 VMAs. Seeing band members walking around in thongs, everyone throwing beer bottles at an exit sign, Marilyn Manson (yes, he's in this too in parts) briging in a rotting animal head, Trent and the rest putting powder all over each other, Trent playing and traveling with his dog, Trent in ruby-red lipstick, and David Bowie chatting with Trent about being mistaken for Vanilla Ice proves that anything can happen. OK, I lied when I said I'd only talk about the backstage footage on tape 1. I HAVE to talk about the Trent and David duo performance of Hurt. I didn't even know it was that song until David starting singing the lyrics. Trust me, it's almost a completely different song musically; it sounds more like a very deep and emotional David Bowie song instead of the original version, which isn't a bad thing. The music itself is very heart-throbbing and it really sounds as if it was written in memory of the desceased. I popped in tape 2 expecting a typical video collection by any other music artist with just a brief graphical introduction consisting of a caption of the video title. Boy, was I ever wrong, and I'm glad I was at that too! Instead of just a simple collection of videos compiled onto a video tape, Trent created sort of a mini-film with some REAL art to it. Segue material consisted of stuff from old 1950s/60s educational film reels to Thomas Edison's "Electrocuting an Elephant" to some of Trent's own creations such as a dead rabbit being swung against a wall while tied to a rope (pretty graphic stuff I might add). I'll also the videos themselves were presented in much greater clarity than I had expected, considering the only time I'd seen them before was when I had *GULP* downloaded them. Again, the rendition of Hurt on this video caught my attention the most. While still a live performance, it had much better video and audio quality to it than on tape 1. It was also creepy yet emotional as well. The somewhat quieter sound of it along with the footage used on the screen at the concert (especially that of the time-lapse video of rotting animals) gave an almost apocalyptic feeling, at least that's the best word I can find the describe what I mean. Oh, and the footage of Wish kicked, 'nuff said. Regardless of what one may think of the video and sound quality of tape 1, this is indeed an essential item for any NIN collector and true fan. I personally think it was worth every penny I paid for it, maybe even more.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
perfectly captures an era,
By
This review is from: Nine Inch Nails: Closure (VHS Tape)
a personal look at what went on backstage at NIN's self-destruct tour. although not as huge a NIN fan as I once was, I've probably watched this set at least a hundred times, and I continue to watch it on occaission just because it truly captures the band at their best. the live performances are so perfectly sloppy and intense... the shabby film quality in parts fits the music and the images so well it is hard to desribe. the whole thing just seems so natural. the second video featuring the actual music videos for NIN's songs are wonderful as well, in particular, the video for GAVE UP. this video, which simply depicts the band plus marilyn manson recording the song in the studio, is my favorite for some reason. maybe just because it humanizes the artists and shows where the music actually comes from.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Closure on DVD!!! And MORE!!!,
By Ryan (Madison, WI) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Nine Inch Nails: Closure (VHS Tape)
Closure is definatly a must have! Perhaps you would like Closure in DVD format instead of VHS? Well, your in luck! In an Q and A session (on the NIN homepage) with Trent Reznor (Mastermind of NIN) Trent says Closure will be in DVD Format (With Extra Content) availabe in Fall 2004! Also, as a side note, The Downward Spiral Deluxe Edition Remixed in 5.1 will be available. And if that wasnt enough Bleedthrough (Trent has not decided if its a 1 or 2 word title) is now scheduled for release in early 2005.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Want to see more reviews on this item?
|
Most recent customer reviews |