Most helpful customer reviews
1.0 out of 5 stars
not much here, July 8 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Color Correction For Digital Video: Using Desktop Tools to Perfect your Image w/CD-Rom (Paperback)
>This book and companion CD is the best book I have ever read >on the subject and this goes back a ways! Well, that still doesn't say much. The author has a good start, but really, this book doesn't tell you much. It describes the history of color correction and mentions some color perception. The examples are ok, but there aren't many. To the untrained eye, some of the pictures (such as the watermelon example) look identical. Were they intended for a different color space ? If so, why was the book released this way? The author mixes industry jargon, such as "Pull back on the blacks" while referencing a color tool that has a label "Shadows". There are at least three sets of jargon used interchangeably, and none are specifically defined set by set. I didn't even know what exactly a midtone was when I bought this book. The index lists a few pages for midtones, but nowhere is this term or most of the others specifically defined. For a "Digital tools" book that spends so much time on analog vector scopes, I'm disappointed that most of the examples were described in words rather than pictures. Overall, this tutorial falls short. I learned a little, but I didn't walk away with much. I don't see the purpose of this book. The CDROM is basically a demo distribution disk. I bet the other glowing reviews are fake. Experienced colorists will find little in this book, and beginners can't learn much. Dear Author, please write another edition and include a DVD of video examples, step by step. Looking forward to your next book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
A deficient but useful book, Feb 14 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Color Correction For Digital Video: Using Desktop Tools to Perfect your Image w/CD-Rom (Paperback)
Unfortunately, this is the best book I have found on the subject. The section on vector scopes and wave forms helped me understand those tools for the first time. That alone made the book worth the purchase price for me. Unfortunately, the rest of the book was not as good. The introduction to color theory was superficial at best, and was not tied into the rest of the book as one would expect. The examples of color corrections were somewhat interesting, but would have been more useful if they included more guidance about why each step was taken. I also found the frequent errors in spelling and grammar rather distracting. The book needed better editing. But even with its deficiencies, I found it worth the price -- if only because I couldn't find anything better on the subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Steep learning curve for DV amateur, Jan 13 2004
This review is from: Color Correction For Digital Video: Using Desktop Tools to Perfect your Image w/CD-Rom (Paperback)
I am a video enthusiast and I use Canopus DVStorm and Premiere for editing of my videos. I was hoping to learn more about color correction in YUV space, using waveform and vectorscope tools and, most importantly, to improve the quality of the videos that I make. This book starts with a very basic theory of color. Then is suddenly takes giant steps towards the color correction technologies. It explaines some but certainly not all parameters and that can be quite frustrating. Particularly the use of YUV parameters is hardly mentioned at all and it is not explained in any of the excercises. Explanation of the use of the waveform is excellent (some questions still remain) and I got a basic understanding how to use the vectorscope. A significant part of the book explains the tools and features of professional systems found in studios. Obviously such systems are much more sophisticated than PC-based NLE systems. I am still looking for book that is geared more towards PC based systems. Still, I found the book inspiring because it made me try my tools in new ways and actually achieve better results. That's what counts for me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|