I bought this book at a convention, thinking I'd have some good reading for the trip home. But when I opened it up, I was hooked! I stayed up until 2am that night, reading one great story after another. There are sixteen stories in this anthology, all very well-written, and in a broad range of genres. Some of them contain smut, and some of it is quite graphic, but there are several stories here that are sweet and fluffy, too (dare I say innocent?). All the stories have a heavy emphasis on romance, which is what sets this book apart from things like the "best of gay erotica" collections. Sex scenes, when they appear, take place after lots of plot and character development, and are written very tastefully.
This book's main weakness, I think, is its lack of focus. There's no theme tying the stories together, no unified style, or even any common element besides "boys' love". It was especially noticeable for me because I read the whole thing in one sitting; a casual reader who samples one or two stories at a time may not even notice. In any case, the stories are still very good, and I didn't feel the lack of focus was bad enough to knock the rating down from five stars.