2.0 out of 5 stars
NY-Style Tidbits--bland, need salt, July 11 2004
Ce commentaire est de: Cooking For Mr Latte (Paperback)
Cooking for Mr. ... Who? Even though I may be the only male member of the species who has read this book--this is *hard core* "chick lit," so stop reading now if that turns you off--I can only assume the title is smugly ironic. C'mon--*no one* cooks for *Mr.* Anybody anymore, right? Ah, but the subtitle ("A food lover's courtship") assures us; dear Ms. Hesser is the food lover--you were expecting maybe the guy with the nickname?--so *she's* doing the courting here, thank you very much. We're back on safe ground.
And this tale starts well because, compared to a bit later on, we're actually reading a tale. The first few "chapters" (I use that term *very* loosely, as does the author) consist of light, gossipy, he-said, she-said banter with good food as a backdrop. They stumble through a first date. He earns his nickname. He makes her dinner. (She's impressed.) Conclusions of each episode detail exact recipes of everything eaten (the author kept a diary). The recipes aren't bad (I even tried a few).
At this point I hope the reader likes how the relationship is going, because by forty pages in the author adjusts the lens on Mr. Latte; he comes back into focus when needed, but we're basically done with him. The remaining 90% of Mr. Hesser's diary gives us Everything You Possibly Wanted To Know About Me. Or at least My Diet. Courtship? I can count on one hand the number of emotional statements, expressions of affection, or even more-than-trifling romantic insights in this book; in case you have to ask, they're nearly all hers. Attraction? *Sex*? Please, this is about, um, food.
And so on it goes--for thirty-seven (count 'em) vignettes, each about 5-6 pages (or approximately the length of a newspaper food column, which Ms. Hesser conveniently writes--for the New York Times) followed by the aforementioned recipes. This structure isn't really *that* awful, but for supporting a bird's eye-view of a courtship, well, this ain't quite Cyrano de Bergerac. Strangled both by its prose and format, 'Mr. Latte' doesn't convey or evoke the slightest wisp of emotional pulse.
By the less-than-breathless ending I was left with a few questions. What in the name of Zeus was Ms. Hesser's affection for her beloved based on? Mutual appreciation of food? Work? Sense of life? Approval from friends and relatives? We're given obtuse hints on all these subjects, but the author never lets us in; we get plenty of food, precious little courtship, and zero emotion.
And finally: how can a food writer who puts away a daily bowl of ice cream, attends an endless stream of dinner parties, and basically never appears to do anything but write and eat (passionately!) still be the ultra-thin chic gal artistically rendered (the retro hair clips are a give-away) thirty-seven times over--not including the cover? Now answering *that* would be a column worthy of courtship! And include the recipes, please.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good book, GREAT recipes, July 7 2004
By A Customer
Ce commentaire est de: Cooking For Mr Latte (Paperback)
So what if you don't agree with Amanda's opinions or lifestyle? Her stories are fun and the recipes are FABULOUS, every single one. I was never that tempted to try her recipes when they appeared in the NY Times magazine. But I've tried at least a dozen in the book, and I must say, not only do they all work, but I've received raves from my family and friends for every recipe I've tried: ginger duck, pasta with lemon and creme fraiche, slow-roasted cod, romesco sauce, etc. etc. Try them and you'll see.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderfully fun and lighthearted, July 1 2004
I completely enjoyed this fun, well-written, witty book. Amanda's writing makes me want to jump off the couch and whip up dish after dish, invite friends over and really enjoy life. I do not understand why some reviewers find her writing offensive- lighten up! She's honest, about herself and others, and I find her and her writing totally appealing. As I often do with a delicious dish, I found myself rationing this book so that I wouldn't finish it too quickly. What a wonderful way to spend a lazy afternoon and learn a thing or two about cooking in the meantime.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No