Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Very Disappointing, Mar 31 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: The Cook's Bible: The Best of American Home Cooking (Hardcover)
This is a book that just doesn't deliver. It reads well and gives the impression that everything will work - well everything doesn't. Things that do work are mediocre and things that don't work, really don't work, just try the pie crust and you'll see what I mean. A good concept, interesting to read, just don't cook from it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Pretty good..., Jan 6 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: The Cook's Bible: The Best of American Home Cooking (Hardcover)
I have the version of "The Cook's Bible" that came as one book together with "The Dessert Bible." If you are at all familiar with Cook's Illustrated Magazine, the format and style will be familiar to you. As for recipes, you will find it all in here -- product tests, exhaustively researched recipes for the food your mom and grandma used to make, etc. Some of the product testing is a little dated, but frankly, I don't base my purchases on Christopher Kimball's opinions anyway. I rely on an amalgam of information from many different sources to determine the best kitchen equipment, ingredients etc. It's a great kitchen resource, but be warned -- if you own this, there's no need for you to buy "The Best Recipe," "The America's Test Kitchen Cookbook," or basically anything else Cook's Illustrated puts out, because the recipes are the same. This book is basically an expanded version of the non-dessert recipes in "The Best Recipe," which I also own. Cook's Illustrated is famous for recycling their recipes over and over and just putting new titles and covers on the cookbooks. If you buy this, don't buy another CI book until you're absolutely positive (through side-by-side comparison) that you need both. The only other criticism I have of this book -- and all the Cook's Illustrated books, really -- is there's not a lot of diversity of cuisines involved. The magazine and cookbooks stick to tried-and-true staples of American (actually Northeastern American) food, and occasionally step a just a little over into ethnic cuisine. But if you're looking for explosive new tastes, interesting fusions of different cuisines, daring flavor combinations, new twists on old standards etc., these are not the cookbooks you're looking for. This would be a great gift for nervous new cook who's interested in learning the fundamentals and needs the reassurance of extensively tested recipes, but there's not a lot of excitement or intrigue here for a cook who's more or less mastered the basics of American cuisine and is now branching out into cooking the food of other parts of the world. A very nice basic "resource" cookbook to have, but definitely not the be-all end-all "bible" of cooking Kimball purports it to be.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
If You Suscribe to Cooks's, You May Want to Reconsider, Dec 10 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: The Cook's Bible: The Best of American Home Cooking (Hardcover)
... If you suscribe to either Cook's Illustrated magazine or receive the hardbound annual editions, you may want to think twice about buying this book. I couldn't pass up the combined Cook's Bible and Dessert Bible at Sam's Club today (which, I might add, doesn't accept book returns). When I arrived home and began to peruse my purchase I realized that I had many similar articles in hardbound Cook's annuals, sitting on my kitchen bookshelf. Fortunately, I only spent [money] for the three inch thick, hardback tome (Sam's Club Members, alert!). It may sit under a bed until next Christmas and transform itself into the perfect gift for a culinarily-challenged family member. I must also concur with Norman OK's assesment of dated comments and advice. Frankly, I've never found Christopher Kimball dull. With so much haphazard cookbook writing and editing out there, I appreciate his painstaking prose. No, he's not Jamie Oliver, but not all of us like the off-the-cuff approach. If one is looking for a good culinary textbook, instead of a recipe book, this is certainly a strong contender.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|