1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good, but....., Dec 6 2000
This review is from: Croatia: A Nation Forged in War (Hardcover)
The book was informative, but it did not go into great detail. The period of 1918-41 was glazed over in a few pages, and the extent of Serbian tyrrany and crimes were not fully covered. The massacre of hundreds of peaceful demonstrators on Ban Jelacic Square (where democratic Croatian protesters were gunned down by the Serbian genedarmerie occupation police) on December 5, 1918, was not mentioned, nor the Brusane massacre, nor the Sinj massacre; nor the extent of Serbian domination and hedgemony in the police and military, as well as the brutal repression of ethnic, civil, human, and national rights. One cannot just breeze over the banning of all free speech, press, assmebly, and culture; nor the Serbian police force's beating, jailing, and liquidation of the democratic opposition. Unfortunately, Lampe, Judah, Tanner, and many others do; by doing so, they commit the fallacy of denying the antecedent. Mr. Diljas accuses Tanner of using "predominately Croatian and pro-Croatian sources;" well, can Mr. Diljas tell us who those sources are? If that downplays the legitimacy of the book, how would Mr. Diljas explain the legitimacy of his books (being that he is a Serb and a Communist) and books written by Serbs and Communists over this past century. Thus, it would be that Mr. Diljas and most books written about Croatia and the ex-Yugoslavia (and all of the former Republics) were not and are not free of Serbian nationalistic and Communist idealistic romanticism, and should be read with Critical reserve.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Seems Good, But Hard To Tell!, Jan 24 2003
My fiancee and I were both really eager to read this book, we'd heard good things about it and are planning a trip to Croatia. Unfortunately, it's so poorly typeset that it's a real struggle to read! We both got about 15-20 pages into it and just couldn't continue, we were getting headaches (no joke). The problem is that the text is just too densely set, there's no breathing room whatsoever. Yale Press has a done a real disservice to the author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting and comprehensive, Aug 26 2000
This review is from: Croatia: A Nation Forged in War (Hardcover)
As the people of a young country, U.S. citizens do not typically relate to the deep ties many foreign cultures have to their homeland. Consequently, Americans may struggle to understand ethnic conflict around the world. Marcus Tanner, an award winning British journalist, explains the historical dynamics of the Balkans in "Croatia: A Nation Forged in War." Events in Croatia's history, like the influence of the Roman Catholic and Orthodox Churches, the Mongol and Ottoman invasions, alliances with the Hungarian and then the Habsburg monarchies, Nazi Germany and Communist coups, and the recent conflicts with Yugoslavia are discussed thoroughly in this detailed study.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No