Crumb (Criterion)

 

 

Create your own review

I really don't know what to make of this film. When you first start watching Crumb, you wonder why anyone would ever want to watch something this odd, but after about twenty minutes you realize that you couldn't stop watching it if you wanted to -- and you don't want to. The world of Robert Crumb, a pioneer in the world of underground comics, is as disturbing as it is fascinating -- and that is exactly what Crumb is, a documentary about the life of this man and his family. It gives you a disarmingly honest look inside the man's mind, and I'm not sure anyone can really describe what we discover. In all honesty, I had never heard of Robert Crumb nor seen any of his work (although Fritz the Cat does ring a bell) before -- that work is eye-opening to say the least, and you get to see a lot of it during the documentary. Much of it is misogynistic and arguably racist, so I'm sure Crumb fans and anti-fans alike will be most interested in this artist's direct insight into his work. Crumb is a compulsive artist who draws almost constantly, and one gets the sense that it is the only thing keeping him from crossing a line into madness.

This is a really strange man, basically a recluse who never seems comfortable with himself or anyone else -- it's quite amazing he would allow a film crew in to follow him around for such a significant amount of time. He's not shy about discussing any part of his life or his work, however, taking us all the way back to his childhood. The man's artistic talents, even as a child, are undoubtedly extraordinary and certainly unique in terms of the exaggerated way he tends to draw things, especially people. Critics on both sides discuss the demeaning, borderline sadistic manner in which he has depicted women at different times in his career, and Crumb readily admits that he has some inward hostility toward women (although he has married twice and is the father of two children). On some issues, though, particularly when it comes to charges of racism, he tends to dance around the questions, passing some of the criticism off as an effect of his drug use in the 1960s.

The most poignant aspect of the film, however, is the story of Crumb's family. In many ways, this is a descent into mental illness -- and it's poignantly tragic. Crumb and his siblings obviously grew up in a dysfunctional family with a particularly puritan, abusive father. His two sisters chose not to be interviewed for this film, but we do meet brothers Charles and Maxon along with Crumb's mother. Charles still lives at home, never leaves the house, and has been dependent on medications for many years (his problems apparently include depression, suicidal tendencies, and homicidal thoughts), while Maxon (who has a record of child molestation from his younger days) seems to be far too disturbed to live on his own as he does. The interviews with Crumb and his brothers are the centerpiece of this documentary, if you ask me, and it's just a terribly sad thing to watch.

Just as Crumb's comics are what they are, Crumb is who he is, as seems clear from the details of this documentary. In some ways, he is incomprehensible and rather repulsive, yet you can't really dismiss or dislike him too much just because he's so darn fascinating and different from the rest of mankind. I think those with an interest in psychology will actually get more out of this film than most of Crumb's fans and critics.

"Crumb" is the sad and funny documentary of a damaged man who happened to find a beautiful and reasonably lucrative outlet for his peccadilloes. It's also the brutal portrait of two men - Robert's brothers - who were not so lucky.

"Crumb" offers amazing access to R. Crumb and his family, but the man himself remains an enigma - an entertaining and fascinating enigma, but an enigma nonetheless. Still, Zwigoff's probing camera gets behind the man and his art, his fans and detractors, and delivers a wonderful portrait of the man and a great appreciation of his work - even his most off-putting, misogynistic work.

But it's when Zwigoff talks to Robert's family that we see the true effects of a horrible, and horror-filled, childhood. Both of his brothers are intelligent and considerably talented, but they were unable to find a healthy outlet to escape a tyrannical father (his abuse is only hinted at in the movie), and their stories are deeply affecting - and difficult to watch.

So "Crumb" is either life-affirming or terribly depressing. I vote for the first option, which is why I'm the proud owner of the DVD. You wont find a much better documentary, or a more powerful drama, than "Crumb."

Wow! I knew R. Crumb was off-beat, but I had no idea how much so. And his family is really messed up, much worse off than Robert Crumb. His siters refused to be interviewed forthe film, but his two brothers should be institutionalized. If you question your own weirdness and sanity, take a look at the Crumb family in comparison; It may cheer you up. Something totally worthwhile is the scene where Crumb is going through his older brother's comics and notebooks. Want to "see someone go insane?" Here you go. Warning, R. Crumb, and his friends and family's honesty is commendable yet some viewers may not appreciate the talk of masturbation, racial slurs, and gender roles.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 51 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

 

5.0 out of 5 stars Thanks to Zwigoff for documenting the Family Crumb
What a fascinating family, so glad they let us glimpse their eccentricities head on, to me it was liberating. Read more

Published on Jun 22 2004 by bookfan

4.0 out of 5 stars not a bad movie if you like dysfunction, greatness
What can you say about the iconclastic artist r. crumb, profane, sexist, racist,pervert, a genuis, this movie explains why in more ways than one his brother is sucidal who had a... Read more

Published on Mar 27 2004 by E. D. Daniels

5.0 out of 5 stars To the dude from Sedona...
....sounds like you're reviewing the PERSON rather than the FILM.

I share R's love of old time blues and big band music and, like many others, I view R. Read more

Published on Feb 22 2004

3.0 out of 5 stars On behalf of Charles...
I own this film and I must say that I like Robert Crumb's taste in the blues and I share a lot of his views about the shallowness of American culture. Read more

Published on Feb 21 2004

5.0 out of 5 stars Extraordinarily intimate and honest
Robert Crumb is the influential creator of seminal underground comics icons such as Mr. Natural and Fritz the Cat. Read more

Published on Feb 9 2004 by David Bonesteel

4.0 out of 5 stars Strangely compelling
With his Mr Magoo glasses big enough to reflect a film crew, Goofy-like body and mouth transfixed into a seemingly permanent wry grin, the satirical artist Robert Crumb looks like... Read more

Published on Jan 19 2004 by deborahinplains

5.0 out of 5 stars Just not made for these times
I`m not a big comic book fan but I was quite aware of American artist Robert Crumb and his crazy drawings. Read more

Published on Jan 18 2004 by R. Cousineau

5.0 out of 5 stars so this is american film...
classifying this film is simple: it's really an apple and oranges type thing. for those looking for a universal medium in the film, some kind of generic entertainment or moral... Read more

Published on Dec 28 2003 by A. Granger

5.0 out of 5 stars ---
crumb is important to me because i watch a lot of movies and i think documentarys as a whole are important because they avoid a lot of the escapism that is key with most movies... Read more

Published on Dec 16 2003 by billbillbillybill

5.0 out of 5 stars Body floss, anyone?
R. Crumb, comic artist and weirdo, laid bare in a documentary about his life and very dysfunctional family. Read more

Published on Aug 7 2003 by J. Eure

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 51 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

Search Listmania!