1.0 out of 5 stars
By the Gods, what have they done to Krynn!, July 30 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: DRAGONLANCE: THE FIFTH AGE (Paperback)
Well, this is it; TSR's monumental 1995 embarrasment. Yep folks, you are looking at the very product that caused TSR to implode, leaving AD&D players in the hands of some n00bs from Wizards of the Coast, who went on to release a quick barrage of AD&D 2nd edition stuff in 1998 and 1999, before discontinuing AD&D 2nd ed completely, and releasing D&D 3rd ed.
This is where it all started....well strictly speaking, that's the novel "Dragons Of Summer Flame", but in terms of game products, this is it. Krynn is ruined. The Gods are gone, so are all your favorite characters.
That's right, no Tanis, or Fizban, or even Tas! They're all dead 'n gone. Goldmoon is still there, as is Laurana, but no one ever really liked them anyway. Caramon and Tika are still alive, but they're in their 70's now.
Magic's gone too, replaced by a new form of sorcery, pretty much invented by Palin.
While the saga system isn't all bad, it doesn't match up to the AD&D 2nd ed. rules. What *really* killed Dragonlance though, was the fact that Weis & Hickman felt the need to change Krynn into a cheap, post-apocalyptic 3rd rate fantasy setting. And believe me, it only gets worse from here... (I do NOT recommend reading War Of Souls).
I applaud it when writers try to add something new to a series, but Weis & Hickman just went on a killing spree with this one. They're just taking risks for the sake of taking risks, cause that's what the critics want, innit?
Like I said, this marked the end of Krynn as one of fantasy roleplaying's most popular settings.
Curiously, after the release of the 5th age product line, TSR's other product lines went downhill as well. Only Ravenloft and Forgotten Realms managed to maintain their high standards for a while (until the release of D&D 3rd ed), while Greyhawk made a succesful comeback in 1998.
Krynn's magic is gone, the three moons took it with them, and it's not coming back, no matter how hard Palin tries...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No