Most helpful customer reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
Takes a few pages to get started, April 28 2004
This review is from: The Dawning of a New Age: Dragons of a New Age, Volume One (Mass Market Paperback)
This book reminds me a lot of the first of the Dragonlance Chronicles. I didn't like it much until I got into the second book. I'm now almost done with the second book in this series and I like it a lot. 350 pages isn't enough to do it justice. I'm always a big fan of making BIG books to completely tell a story. I think with a few hundred more pages this book could have been spectacular. As it stands, I'm pleased with this book, I liked the idea of the Dragon overlords, I liked the links that are being made to other Dragonlance stories, but felt the characters were not very fleshed out. And the action scenes were rushed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
A slow start that gets better, Mar 26 2004
This review is from: The Dawning of a New Age: Dragons of a New Age, Volume One (Mass Market Paperback)
Jean Rabe constantly takes abuse from Dragonlance fans around the globe for a plethora of reasons. Some I've found to be just, others, I believe are unfounded. It was because of this harsh critism that I remained hesitant for a good while to read this book. After finishing every other book I owned and reading some for a second time, I grudgingly began this read. At my own admission, this book began very slowly. The first 100 pages seemed plaqued by choppy writing, and seemingly overly fantastic ideas. Given this is a fantasy book, I still found some of the happenings in the book a bit hard to swallow. My biggest critism of the book,however, has to do with the how willingly the author let years go by without description(literaly decades). It seemed to me that the amount of time that passed in te early portion of this book really didn't mean much to Mrs. Rabe. I have to say I was seriously starting to doubt whether or not I would finish this one. All the critism aside, after the first 100 pages or so the plot settled down and the writting began to become enjoyable. I was finally able to get involved with the characters and wanted to see what would happen to them next. By the end of the book I was left wanting more. When all is said and done, that to me is the most important part of a book in a series. I really admire the guts that it took for Jean to step out on a limb and write this series. I've found that many DL fans can be very critical, and unmoving in thier willingness to branch out and discover new things. Jean did something that was very difficult, in filling the gap that is the beginning of the Fifth Age. Kodus to her! All in all, I think this book is a enjoyable read that will leave most readers wanting more. For those diehard DL fans it is a must read. Looking back, my gripe about the passage of time allows, hopefully, other authors to fill the gap with other tells of heroism and valor. Don't go into this book expecting the kind of greatness that is the Chronicles series or maybe The Legand of Huma(my personal favorite), because you won't find it. There isn't a ton of depth and you probably won't develop a strong attachment to the characters. DoNA starts slowly, but levels off into a nice story. I believe if you press on and overlook the choppy writing at the begining you will leave this book pleasantly surprised. I did.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
I shouldn't have bought them all at once, Jun 12 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: The Dawning of a New Age: Dragons of a New Age, Volume One (Mass Market Paperback)
I'm certainly not an experienced Dragonlance fan, but I must say that this book is just not right. It just doesn't seem like a credible Dragonlance story at all. First, the gods abandon the entire world, leaving dragons to do as they wish. There's not magic left, except in magic items. Even though Dragons have enough power to clone themselves and transform landscapes, one of the main dragon characters goes on a quest to steal magic items so he can gather enough power to open a portal. Go figure. The relationship between this dragon and his dead companion was not believeable either. "Oh, I have to resurrect my friend," but then he goes off on some tangent with a red dragon who wants to turn all humanity and the like into cattle. In addition, the dragons are overly immense, and one of them destroys the great tower of palanthas! Preposterous! The author, unsuccessfully, tries to gather a group of rag-tag heroes to start a new revolution. The book just gets stupider and stupider. It's possible that this could have been good, but the whole premise obviously went south. A 2-star rating is probably fair.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|