Deadly Choices: How the Anti-Vaccine Movement Threatens Us All [Hardcover]

The focus of Deadly Choices is on the history of the introduction of new vaccines and the anti-vaccine movements that tend to follow. Offit is a prominent virologist and he doesn't hide his scorn for some in the anti-vaccine movement. His book is unlikely to change the minds of anyone who is firmly within that movement, but I'm not sure what would. The book is a must read for anyone interested in a detailed, well-written, and thoroughly sourced discussion of the scientific basis of vaccines, the real and imagined risks of vaccination, and the consequences of the choices we make about vaccines.

The politics of the vaccine debate are powerful, and they often overshadow the substance. It's remarkable how many people managed to read and write "reviews" of this book within 2 days of its release on December 28. A few even managed to review the book before it was released! Given that few of these reviews mention anything about the book's contents, I suspect many of the reviewers, both positive and negative, have not read it.

I actually have read the book. Given that I had written about the vaccine/autism debate in the past (from the perspective of trying to understand the sorts of evidence people use when drawing causal conclusions), I requested and received a review copy of the book from the publisher 6 weeks before its publication.

Not surprisingly, the book thoroughly documents some of the unfounded claims that the anti-vaccine movement has made and explains the biological reasons why some of the perceived risks of vaccines either are not a risk or physiologically CAN'T be a risk. For example, many of the "green our vaccines" campaigns are based on the concern that there are nasty chemicals in vaccines, which is true. As Offit notes, though, it's not the substance that's the problem, it's the dose. Even water is toxic when taken in a large enough dose (on occasion, college students die during frat hazings when required to drink too much water at once). Most of the substances that scare people away from vaccines (e.g., aluminum and formaldehyde) are in our bodies and blood stream all the time. Our foods contain them, and the quantities in vaccines are relatively negligible. Similarly, babies are exposed to countless bacteria and viruses, so the fact that children get a seemingly large number of vaccines does not mean that those vaccines tax the immune system at all (Offit also notes that it's not the number of vaccines, but the number of elements within those vaccines that require an immune response).

The book is not one-sided. The first chapters discuss all of the well-documented cases of actual vaccine injury and the real side effects of vaccines (e.g., the live polio vaccine could cause polio, although most vaccines don't use live viruses). The book uses these tragic cases to document how the CDC and regulatory agencies now catch really rare side effects that didn't show up in the large-scale testing necessary for approval (side effects that are 1 in a million sometimes don't show up in testing with 50,000 people). Vaccines undergo more rigorous testing than other drugs, and the mechanisms in place to detect rare side effects work far more effectively than they do for other drugs. In order to introduce a new vaccine into the recommended schedule, testing must show that it doesn't interact in any way with the remainder of the schedule.

Offit also discusses some of the things that vaccine safety advocates could do (but haven't done) to help make vaccines safer. For example, people who have egg allergies cannot get vaccines that are made using chicken eggs (e.g., flu vaccine). There might well be alternative ways to make such vaccines, but the pharmaceutical industry has no financial or government-initiated incentives to develop those alternatives. Vaccine safety advocates could push them to do so.

Offit makes the case that anti-vaccine movements raise fears of vaccines that are inconsistent with the science. In so doing, he draws parallels between current anti-vaccine claims and those made over a century ago after the introduction of the smallpox vaccine. Many of the fears of that vaccine are laughable by today's standards (e.g., that children would develop cow-like facial features because the vaccine was initially taken from cows infected by cowpox). But Offit argues, fairly convincingly, that the logic and nature of current anti-vaccine scares are largely the same as those raised over a century ago and in each subsequent anti-vaccine movement. He also shows that most of the anti-vaccine proponents as well as self-identified vaccine safety advocates (including Dr. Bob) lack any relevant background in virology, epidemiology, or statistics, and that they typically lack the training to evaluate the actual risks of vaccines.

The most compelling chapter is the last one, in which Offit describes what happens when someone who could not be vaccinated (because they were too young) comes into contact with an infected child whose parents decided not to vaccinate. The choice not to vaccinate affects people other than your own child--it puts young infants and others whose bodies lack a typical immune response can't be vaccinated at risk. The chapter is reminiscent of the recent PBS Frontline documentary on vaccinations.

At times, the book can be a bit heavy handed in its tone--Offit's perspective is clear throughout, and he doesn't hold his punches. Sometimes his parallels between historical anti-vaccine movements and current ones are a little forced, and in a few cases, the book is perhaps a bit more dismissive than is necessary. For example, in passing Offit implies that all chiropractors reject the germ theory of disease. Although a rejection of the germ theory might have motivated chiropractors at the start, I'd hazard a guess that most present-day chiropractors accept the germ theory of disease. Overall, though, the book presents the scientific evidence in a compelling, comprehensive, thoroughly documented, and engaging way.

For prospective parents whose prior information about vaccines comes from friends, the internet, or even their pediatrician, this book is a must read by one of the top scientific experts in the field. It provides the background and evidence you need to evaluate claims about the dangers and benefits of vaccines and to make the best choice for your children AND your community.

Dr. Paul Offit has written a great book that all parents should read if they're on the fence about vaccinating their kids. In the past decade or so, the internet and TV have given a powerful voice to people like Jenny McCarthy and her ex-boyfriend Jim Carrey to attack vaccines as being bad for kids and society in general, making allegations that have long been put to rest.

Offit doesn't present the picture that all vaccines are great and never cause problems. To the contrary, he lays out the problems with certain vaccines but also how these problems were found and corrected. He also highlights why the idea of the "herd" protections of vaccines will protect the unvaccinated is wrong, pointing out where certain diseases have arisen again due to high rates of unvaccinated children and pointing to instances where children for whom vaccines don't work because their immune systems are compromised are at risk because the kids around them are getting diseases a vaccine could prevent.

Offit rightly attacks the reporters, celebrities, pundits, lawyers, and doctors that provide misinformation about vaccines as well as providing the trends in anti vaccine movements throughout history.

Offit's final point is probably its most important. The anti vaccine movement has arisen, like many of today's angry (and ignorant) movements, from distrust of institutions. The anti vaccine forces point to pharmaceutical companies and the government as attacking freedoms and experimenting on our kids for profit. Offit says that the pro vaccine movement needs more "human" faces, from the researchers who pour their passion into preventing diseases to the parents who can provide a counterpoint to Jenny McCarthy's ignorance, showing the way in which NOT having their child vaccinated caused their child harm.

I cannot praise this book and its author enough. The courage shown by Dr Offit is matched only by his knowledge and expertise. This man, who devoted 25 years of his life to give us the rotavirus vaccine, has reluctantly abandoned his beloved laboratory in order to write this book denouncing the evil people who deny children the relief from pain and suffering offered by vaccines.

I was shocked at the number of so-called humans devoting their lives to making children suffer. The number of TV buffoons, Hollywood air-heads and talk-show bumpkins that flood our media with ignorant nonsense is flabbergasting. It is shameful that a man of Dr Offit's importance has to spend his valuable time refuting the incoherent ramblings of this credulous mob.

I was embarrassed to read that Dr Oz does not give his children the flu vaccine because his wife, who believes in some weird nonsense called Reiki, has overruled Dr Oz despite his MD degree and the 250 heart surgeries he performs annually.

The uncaring cruelty of the Christian Scientists is truly shocking. The cold, calculating way the Christian Scientists slowly and agonizingly kill their children, even though a simple shot in the arm could save them, clearly demands the death penalty. I was very pleased to read that Edward Whitney, the loving father of his daughter, Aubrey, shot dead the Christian Scientist 'doctor' who deliberately took her off insulin causing her death from a diabetic coma.

The activities of these people are putting all of us at risk. If a child who is too young to have yet received his vaccination is placed in a classroom with older children who have deliberately not been vaccinated, then the child is at risk of dying. This is not right.

Dr Offit praises Henry Waxman, California Democrat, whose bill, National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act, saved vaccines from a crippling assault by the nation's ambulance chasers. Henry Waxman deserves all our thanks.

When Dr Offit attends government hearings he requires security guards to protect him. His mail is examined before opening. Yet this good man continues to risk his life to save the lives of our 'little ones'.

This good man has earned our respect and our gratitude.

› Go to Amazon.com to see all 62 reviews  3.6 out of 5 stars