Most helpful customer reviews
1.0 out of 5 stars
Dwindling patience, Oct 17 2002
Normally I am a patient person who can sit through even the most daunting of books, but not this one. The book began quite well and seemed to be turning into quite the spiritual experience (in reference to Vishnu's "flashbacks"). Somewhere along the way the self absorbed inhumane characters began testing my patience at every turn. My anxiety increased until I decided that if I tried to read the whole book I may start believing that hitting myself over the head with it may be less frustrating than "watching" these people bicker over the mundane details of their hopelessly dead end lives instead of recognizing the true spirituality in life and death, as Vishnu is finally doing (in his death, which I guess is supposed to be the author's attempt at irony????). One the whole I would not recommend this book, save for the first half. (FYI I did read the whole thing just so I could write this and my worst fears became reality, it didnt get any better)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fabulous, May 30 2002
The Death of Vishnu has become one of my absolute favorite novels. Although some reviews have called its characters a representative microcosm of India, I believe the message is much simpler and much broader than that. This is a book about human nature, in all its ugliness and glory. The characters are superbly well drawn--sometimes they come across as despicable, other times sympathetic, but they are always heartbreakingly real. Watch how all thier seemingly altruistic acts have selfish human motives behind them and you will recognize yourself. One of the nicest things about this book is the odd little quirks that Manil Suri gives his characters. Mr. Jalal (my favorite) trying to burn himself with pink candles in order to achieve spiritual enlightment, Mrs. Pathak serving kraft cheese as a foreign delicacy, Kavita's obsession with Hindi films, Sheetal's dying wish to make it into the Guiness Book of World Records...and of course Vishnu, who starts to wonder if he might be god. It's a rich tapestry, and so very different from anything I've ever read before...Despite the aimless nature of the plot, the novel still built up a great deal of suspense at the end, and unlike most supposedly "suspenseful" stories I honestly had no idea how everything was going to turn out. And when I finally finished it I was left with a greater understanding of how human beings can be so horrible in so many little ways. I believe this is a book everyone would benefit from reading, not just people specifically interested in India or Indian fiction. However, it should be noted that there is a great deal of Hindu mythology in this book. Being Indian myself I was familiar with most of it, but other readers might want to get a little background information beforehand.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A superb social novel by a gifted, ambitious writer, Sep 10 2001
First off, let me confess that I was predisposed to like this book. I've been enjoying the latter-day Golden Age of South Asian literature for some time now, and I picked up Mr. Suri's novel with the expectation that it would be filled with colorful characters, comical arguments, and telling details of domestic life, all conveyed in exuberant prose. Such elements are de rigeur in post-Rushdie Indian fiction, and if those are what you're after, The Death of Vishnu does not disappoint. Indeed, after the first few chapters, I had settled in for what I fully expected to be a somewhat predictable read about a battle of wits between two middle-aged couples over what to do with the dying Vishnu, interspersed with scenes from the dying man's life. But then the book took some unexpected and delightful turns and became much better in the process. New characters were introduced who complicated all the various relationships and greatly expanded the social reach of the novel; Vishnu's spirit separated from his body and started to climb the stairs; a few of the characters' fascination and identification with film stars became increasingly pronounced; things started to get, shall we say, a little trippy. (Believe me, I'm not giving away anything here.) Toward the end, as the book becomes by turns suspenseful, mythic and surreal, I could not stop turning the pages. As I write this, it's been a couple of weeks since I finished the book, and I still find myself flashing on particular scenes, as if I'd seen them happening before my eyes. (Try to go to sleep after reading the description of the man dangling by his fingertips off the edge of a balcony--go ahead, try!) Unlike most first novelists, Suri does not even attempt to resolve all of the plot issues by the end of the novel--indeed, he leaves one woman's story in particular agonizingly unsettled--but nevertheless the book left me with a remarkable sense of completeness. That is the mark of a truly gifted writer, which Manil Suri surely is, and I look forward to his second novel with bated breath.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|