From Publishers Weekly
Alternative realities and parallel plot lines coexist in Ursu's surreal but psychologically acute second novel (after Spilling Clarence), in which a boy chosen from a circus audience to disappear during a clown's magic act really does disappear. Hannah and Justin Woodrow bring their daughter, Greta, to the circus for her seventh birthday, along with her five-year-old brother, James. Greta is outgoing, quick-witted and full of energy, while James is so quiet his mother plans to bring him to a specialist for tests. Both parents thrill when James is selected from the audience and responds charmingly to the clown's every request. Then, suddenly, James is gone. The police assign someone to watch over the family, but the officer turns from friend to aggressor while Mike the Clown is transformed from suspect to victim. Hannah dissociates, Justin obsesses and Greta does research. The child is the only one who is able to confront the loss directly. Ursu mixes realistic depictions of police interrogations and domestic tensions with fantastic interludes like a chapter imagining the day after James's disappearance as it would have been if the disappearance had not occurred. She delicately probes the worry and longing, guilt and rage, protectiveness and resentment that characterize parental love. James's "disapparation" is even more a mystery at the end of the novel than at the beginning, but it doesn't seem to matter, since Ursu wins the reader over with her humane wisdom and charming vision of the limitless possibilities of a child's imagination. One only wishes that Greta-the novel's pivotal character-were not quite so cloying.
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Hannah and Justin Woodrow are enjoying a night out at a circus show with their two children, Greta and James. They are celebrating Greta's seventh birthday, and she is popping up and down in her auditorium seat unable to control her excitement over the impending show. This is not unusual for Greta, but five-year-old James, who is usually reserved and self-contained, is equally restless, and the Woodrows are quietly pleased by his recent burst of animation. When Mike the Clown makes his way onto the stage for the grand finale, he asks for a volunteer, and James surprises the Woodrows again by eagerly raising his hand. The clown chooses James to help him with a disappearing trick, and before the crowd's disbelieving eyes, little red-haired James Woodrow evaporates into thin air. Ursu maneuvers her characters through the stages of parental grief in a credible and insightful fashion, but does not support James' disappearance with physical or esoteric information, which leaves a void in what is otherwise a very innovative work of fiction.
Elsa GaztambideCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved