4.0 out of 5 stars
Top- Notch Production Highlights this GBV Effort, May 13 2004
This review is from: Do The Collapse (Audio CD)
Guided by Voices was known in its early days for its "garage band" sound, a tribute to the low- fi production on its music CD's. With "Do the Collapse", GBV made a sizable leap toward a more polished, well- produced sound, thanks to the album's producer, Ric Ocasek, former lead singer for the Cars. His influence can be felt on the first track, "Teenage FBI" (Ocasek even plays the keyboards on this song), and elsewhere on this musical collection.
The most memorable things about the songs on this CD are the unusual, quirky lyrics supplied by front man Bob Pollard and the music itself, which takes off in several different directions from one song to the next and sometimes even within the same tune. "Hold on Hope" is a soft, but powerful ballad. "Teenage FBI" and "Zoo Pie" have a techno- pop sound. "In Stitches" and "Much Better, Mr. Buckles" feature the thrashing, grinding guitar of Doug Gillard. "Liquid Indian" is dark and mystifying, while tunes like "Optical Hopscotch" cannot really be placed in any musical category at all.
"Do the Collapse" is an interesting album with weird song titles and lyrics, yet catchy musical hooks. It was the first time that GBV got serious about production by hiring the well- known musical talent Ric Ocasek as the albums main producer. It was also the first time that GBV attempted to create a pop song, with the memorable track "Teenage FBI". It didn't become the pop phenomenon that the band would have liked, but it did introduce GBV music to an entirely new audience.
Whether you're a die- hard fan of Guided by Voices or a casual listener, you will enjoy "Do the Collapse". Older fans may be reluctant to give this CD a spin, since it doesn't have the raw, basement- taped sound of the earlier GBV material. But it's still worth a listen. You wouldn't want to be without such great songs as Hold on Hope, Surgical Focus, and Liquid Indian.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Their Best record to start with, Feb 26 2004
This review is from: Do The Collapse (Audio CD)
If you are new to GBV, this is a good one to start with. Pollard consistently writes beautiful, silly, acidic lyrics and the band sounds great.
From there I would send you to try earlier discs like Alien Lanes, Bee Thousand with some warning about their lo-fi aesthetic. Which I love. I have all their records.
They are truly Guided by Beer, and I love where it takes them.
They put out a new record about every 5 minutes, all good-to-great, but this is very consistent and almost normal sounding. A great introduction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sneaky Good, Sep 22 2003
This review is from: Do The Collapse (Audio CD)
OK, so maybe this is no news to Guided By Voices fans, but to these relatively unfamiliar ears, this is a CD that -- while I don't get it out too often -- gets better with each play. Arrangements often rock and are never less than melodic. Lyrics are intelligent and (very) offbeat. Each song is distinct, albeit usually unfathomable, and the Voices will never be accused of being a one-sound group. Teenage FBI, Things I Will Keep, Dragons Awake!, and Liquid Indian are the four best of this excellent collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No