From School Library Journal
Grade 2-5–Dog, raised by Black Nose in a dump after surviving near drowning as a puppy, is soon adrift when Black Nose is killed by a falling refrigerator. He makes his way through the harsh realities of the dog pound, life on the street, travel on the Metro, and a stop with a kindly man and dog before landing with an erratic and manipulative child, Plum, and her indulgent parents. Plum initially cherishes her new companion but abandons him when her interests (and the plot) wander elsewhere. Dog runs away, but later rejoins the family, only to have Mr. Muscle and Mrs. Squeak, as he refers to Plum's parents, dispose of him. He rallies his companions to trash the apartment but save Plum's room, and ends up with her once again, but this time, supposedly, loved and cherished by the child and tolerated with some respect by Mr. Muscle. Italic passages conveying Dog's depressing thoughts and terrified dreams, plus rueful asides from the author, contribute to the overall weight of the story. While the narrative has some of the tone and misanthropy of Roald Dahl's
Matilda (Viking, 1988), it more closely resembles Meindert DeJong's more kindly, better focused, and ultimately more satisfying
Hurry Home, Candy (HarperCollins, 1953).
–Susan Hepler, Burgundy Farm Country Day School, Alexandria, VA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From Booklist
Gr. 3-5. There are kid-wants-dog books galore, but few reveal what typically happens after the pup comes home. In this one, a canine narrator offers a realistic perspective. Dog, a stray that lives in the dump, has been advised that happiness lies in a bond with a human. He ends up with a little girl, but eventually her enthusiasm for her new pet fades to tolerance and then to devastating apathy. Heartbroken, Dog escapes and befriends Hyena, a wise old canine whose gentle guidance leads him to a deeper understanding of human peculiarities and, eventually, a reunion with his now-repentant former owner. Though the people in Dog's life are a bit broadly characterized, the dog's-nose view of the world is cleverly conceived (a town is "just a dump that's bigger and more spread out and fresher smelling"), and the picaresque quality of the narrative makes this excellent for chapter-a-day sharing. Adams provides an understated English translation of Pennac's original text, which was first published in France in 1982.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.