3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Very interesting & rather well written up to Chapter 10, then dies for the balance., Aug 25 2009
This review is from: Dry Spring: The Coming Water Crisis of North America (Paperback)
I enjoyed the information in this book, liked that it was written by a Canadian and looked forward to a balanced and impartial journalistic report on the status of our most valuable resource. From Chapter One to Nine, it was enjoyably readable. Starting at Chapter 10, it appeared to be written by someone different than the author of the first 9 Chapters.
It became a right-wing rant on why water should be privately owned, privately managed, and spent much energy attacking the book "Blue Gold" (which I haven't read - yet) - and spoke in first-person as a strong proponent for the "market is best to manage" approach to water management, and water rights should be divorced from the land it occupies.
As it was written before the "market management" blundered by fraud and ineptness into the worst recession since the '29 Crash, perhaps he is rethinking his book.
I went into the book with high expectations and initially enjoyed the "facts" and "situations" very much. I lost it all with the right-wing "we want to own it all" proposition for the balance of the book.
I'm very disappointed in this work. I had expected far far better. But now I'm intrigued to the point that I will be ordering "Blue Gold" to see what so inflamed this author.
I have an ethical and moral problem with the idea of denying people water because they may not be able to "pay" for it, so this may be my basic horror in reading this work.
I found the proposals in it scary to say the least. The author makes statements from Chapter 10 onwards that are accusatory of others, while making unsubstantiated and unsupported statements as fact ('trust me'). Where did the "journalist" go after Chapter 9 I wonder? I can only guess that he must've received his Republican Party Corporate Membership card and proceeded on writing with wild abandon.
Just because you can write a book, doesn't translate into it having any redeeming features. This one started well, then went to pot in a hurry.
Save your money -- buy something else. No doubt there are other, better written, better researched, more impartial and better supported books than this drivel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No