16 of 16 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dublin digitally discerned and declaimed, Oct 15 2006
By John L Murphy "Fionnchú" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Dubliners Cd Unabridged (Audio CD)
Handsomely produced, elegantly assembled, and consistently engrossing: these actors read the stories with appropriate sensitivity, wit, pathos, and distance. The detachment of Joyce in his "voice" on the page is re-created well. When I have taught students "Araby" or "The Boarding House," the chance to hear the language repeated as its author would have meant it to be rendered makes these stories come alive for a classroom six thousand miles and a century away from early 20c Dublin.
Although all of the stories succeed, those in the center of the book emerged when conveyed aloud most enlighteningly. Clay, A Mother, A Painful Case, and most of all Two Gallants, After the Race, and Counterparts all hit my ear with more force than they had when I had only read them. These stories are often overlooked compared to the others, but the skill that the actors brought to these more prosaic, less lively, and more nuanced examples of Joyce's careful craft deserve special acclaim. The packaging keeps the CDs securely in place, is itself compact and well-designed, fitting its outwardly austere & Edwardian yet subtly decorated and inviting contents.
Students, the curious newcomer, the experienced teacher, and those who read the book out of delight and not duty: all will benefit from the music on the page that by a technology Joyce himself spoke into at its early gramaphone stages is now digitally preserved so that those of us all over the world and a vastly changed world later can be entertained and instructed. I think JJ might have been pleased at this version of his pioneering, eloquent, yet accessible and moving, accounts of his imagined neighbors and municipal counterparts.
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Joyce Is Meant to Be Read Aloud, Oct 4 2007
By John F. Rooney - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Dubliners Cd Unabridged (Audio CD)
James Joyce was absorbed by music, people, languages, acting and actors, and though an exile from his native country and city, his literary consciousness was forever embedded in Dublin. He had an unerring ear for Dublin dialogue.
At night I turn out the lights and listen to these CD's, to the cadences of the people talking, and to me these Dubliners endlessly gossiping are in the room with me. Joyce's narrative adroitness, his choice of words, his lyrical descriptions, and above all, his sense of place are brilliant facets of a genius.
Stephen Rea's sensitive reading of "The Dead" is worth the price of this set of fifteen stories read by fifteen different mostly Irish personalities. The characters in the stories live and breathe, become real. Joyce was meant to be read aloud. It's good talk, conversations that you become a part of.
In these stories Joyce is very accessible. In Finnegan's Wake he became Jackson Pollock--obscure and difficult. In "The Dead" you can feel, touch, hear, and taste the snow that is falling outside the house while inside two old sisters are giving their annual bright and cheery party. It's a story of tenderness, love, regrets, and lost lovers, but it is mainly full of life, good times, fellowship, and above all humanity.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Who's Afraid of James Joyce?, Mar 1 2011
By Cariola "malfi" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Dubliners Cd Unabridged (Audio CD)
If you've avoided James Joyce after hearing horror stories about the difficulty of reading 'Ulysses' and 'Finnegan's Wake,' put them aside and grab onto this extraordinary collection of Joyce's early short stories. These fifteen stories, each beautifully read by an Irish actor or writer, are funny and poignant and full of the unique atmosphere of Dublin. The perfect introduction to Joyce. Don't miss this one!