We have enjoyed the Eating Out movies quite a lot. The writing has been spot on and the characters very entertaining. But we found that this one was not as funny as the previous three. There are a few good one-liners, but not enough. Notably missing from the cast was Rebekah Kochan as Tiffani (who only had a small role). The new female foil, Lilach Mendelovich as Penny, was a poor substitute. All of the boys, especially Chris Salvatore and Aaron Milo, are adorable, but they just don't have the material to work with on this one. We have also bought Eating Out: The Open Weekend, and are hoping it will be better.