2.0 out of 5 stars
You Have To Give Konrad Some Credit, May 30 2004
EMBERS takes place in 1939 Hungary on a country estate near Budapest. The story begins with the arrival of a letter. In this letter, Henrik, a former Austrian general, learns that he is going to receive a visit from his childhood friend and onetime fellow officer, Konrad, the man who once betrayed Henrik with Henrik's beautiful wife, Krisztina and who Henrik has not seen in forty years.
Krisztina has been dead for thirty-two years and since that time, with the exception of the servants, Henrik has been the estate's only inhabitant. Once he learns of Konrad's impending arrival, he immediately begins making preparations for the visit, seeking to recreate, down to the candles, silver, flowers and food, the last dinner he, Krisztina and Konrad shared together. This dinner followed a long day of hunting that changed the lives of all three persons forever.
Before Konrad's arrival, however, we learn about Henrik's childhood and his first meeting with Konrad at the Imperial Military Academy. It is, in fact, Konrad who introduces Henrik to the beautiful Krisztina.
Henrik believed that he, Konrad and Krisztina comprised an inseparable threesome until the day he is betrayed by both friend and wife, a betrayal he discovers only when Krisztina fails to control herself and utters two revealing words.
Henrik's world falls apart. He retreats to his hunting lodge and he and Krisztina never see each other again; she dies eight years later. Henrik severs his friendship with Konrad, not speaking to him for forty years.
On the night of Konrad's visit, however, Henrik certainly makes up for his forty-year silence. EMBERS is almost a monologue-a rant even-as Henrik unleashes all his long pent up fury and rage. I found this "almost monologue" far too long-winded and melodramatic. I feel the book would have been vastly improved had Marai let Konrad speak instead of writing a long diatribe directed against him. I could understand Henrik's rage, but, my goodness, it's been forty years, I felt like telling him, get over it. Konrad did betray Henrik's trust and friendship but Konrad certainly deserves credit for staying the night and listening to the bitterness of an old man who can't get over the injustices of life and the foibles of love.
While Marai writes elegant, lovely prose, I really can't understand the popularity of this book. The story is terribly predictable and the ranting bitterness of Henrik gets to be "too much." I really wouldn't recommend EMBERS, but if you do read it and, like me, don't like it, be comforted. It's a short book and it really won't take up much of your time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
There is much more than "friendship" at stake ..., May 11 2004
This review is from: Embers (Paperback)
The title "Embers" makes this reader think of a smoldering fire -- one either ready to die out-- or ready to be reawakened -- into a full blazing *fire*. Indeed, the metaphor fits ... the unexpected shock of *what* it is that could erupt into a flame ... and why the title fits, becomes cystal clear about half-way thorugh the book. Similar to Franz Kafka, Marai builds a personal tension that becomes an existential experience, a psychological conundrum -- for the General (Henrik). The General has lived with certain questions... questions he needs answered. The book begins with the General describing his boyhood friendship with Konrad. The friendship began in military school during the Austro-Hungarian empire. The General was of an upper class background, Konrad's parents sold their land and lived on the edge of poverty to provide their son, an advantage in life. The General's father made an observation about Konrad, the first time he visited their home. Konrad was playing a Chopin piece with Henrik's mother, when Henrik's father made a very telling observation about Konrad, "He is different kind of man". This observation sets up the mystery which the book gradually ... very gradually reveals. It is the reason why the book is so intriguing and fascinating. The reader wants to discover ... why is Konrad 'different'. Just what does this mean?
The General is preparing his castle for Konrad's visit. The friends are going to reunite after 41 years of separation. Although, they remained on the best of terms as the closest of friends for 24 years ... something happened ... it made Konrad leave, without a word. The General needed to know, why did Konrad take off ... no word of good-bye ... to explore the world. Konrad often stayed at the General's castle and dined with the General and his wife, Krisztina. This reader suspected that somehow Krisztina held the key ... to his unexpected and unexplained departure. However there is a deeper unexplained ... primitive ... dark secret ... waiting to be unraveled. It is revealed in elegant prose. The book is deeply moving and filled with suspense ... a mesmerizing experience. Erika Borsos (erikab93)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not Quite Classic Status, April 23 2004
This review is from: Embers (Paperback)
EMBERS is an excellent novel, and Marai was obviously an accomplished story teller, but I can't concur that this work ranks with the likes of Kafka, Mann or even Zweig, as the Die Ziet reviewer enthuses in one of the cited reviews. There is merit in the crtic's comparing Marai to Joseph Roth, however. I would even venture to guess that Roth's The Radetzky March had some bearing on Marai's depiction of the old General who is the central character in the novel. There is also the common theme of the death throes of the Austro-Hungarian Empire and the rigid, yet elegant social standards it represented.
The General is like Roth's Grandfather Trotta, as he represents the old military code, that first and foremost demanded strict and total subservience to the Emporer and his cause. One's every thought and every waking breath was dictated by tradition and unbroken order. Pitted against him in Marai's work are his best friend and his young wife, who represent spontaneity, passion and modernity. The General comes to the insight that he was the complacent, self assured stalwart slave to convention and that Krisztina and Konrad were "different," and part of the subtext of the story is an almost Derrida like treatment of "the other."
What prevents- this from being a work of the first rank is Marai's partial failure in providing a compelling narrator. The General is just too long winded and formal a figure to sustain the narrative in any truly convincing manner. I did enjoy the way in which Marai unfolds information, however, and thought that the plot was handled masterfully. It reminded me of an Egoyan movie, in which the culminating revelation slowly and gradually comes into focus, while the audience remains in suspense.
I definitely recommend the read. It doesn't take long, and Marai's prose is indeed as elegant as a display of Viennese dressage. I'm happy that the book was rediscovered and adequately translated. I look forward to the promised future Knopf editions of Marai's works.
BEK
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No